How to Build a Better Boy (2014)

  1. BACKGROUND
  2. PLOT
  3. CHARACTERS & CAST
  4. MUSIC
  5. PRODUCTION
  6. RECEPTION
  7. LEGACY
  8. FINAL THOUGHTS
  9. REFERENCES

BACKGROUND

In the early 2010s, my favourite Disney Channel series and movies were all ending, like Sonny with a Chance (2009-11), Camp Rock, and Wizards of Waverly Place (2007-12). Disney Channel was moving away from the stars I’d grown up with, so I decided it was time I moved on from Disney Channel too.

For the most part, that was true, although Descendants and Liv and Maddie (2013-17) occasionally brought me back. But every time I watched trailers or adverts on Disney Channel at that time for new shows or DCOMs, I felt like the whole channel was changing and it was becoming something very different from what I’d known as a tween or teen.

If you talk to anyone who has watched Disney Channel, they will tell you that whatever was on when they were watching was the best, therefore, their era of Disney Channel was superior to any other. So, the 2010s are not “my era”, and they never will be. I will always prefer what was on in the 2000s to anything from the 2010s onwards. My stars were Selena Gomez, Miley Cyrus, and Demi Lovato.

But those watching in the 2010s had their own stars, many of whom became household names, like Zendaya, Dove Cameron, and China Anne McClain. The 2010s hold their breakout moments, thanks to a mixture of leading roles in series and star performances in Disney Channel Original Movies. Just one of these was 2014’s How to Build a Better Boy.

As we all know, Disney Channel like to put well-known Disney names front and centre of their movies. It’s good for viewership and good for business. In this case, they took China Anne McClain from A.N.T Farm (2011-14) and teamed her up with Kelli Berglund from Lab Rats (2012-16) for this film.

I had not seen How to Build a Better Boy before, apart from perhaps seeing a few clips. I also hadn’t seen Kelli Berglund in anything previously, although I did know McClain from various Disney and non-Disney projects beforehand. I’ve always liked her. That definitely helped me like this movie more than perhaps I would have had the two leads both been completely unknown to me.

How to Build a Better Boy was not the best DCOM I’ve ever seen, but it wasn’t the worst either. I found it was fairly entertaining and watchable, mostly because the premise was not unique to me, whereas this seems to have irritated others, who called it a “rip off”, as it is quite similar to a certain 1980s John Hughes comedy.

PLOT

How to Build a Better Boy begins with the US Army and Department of Defense pursuing two fugitives who have stolen a $3 billion weapon from the government. The fugitives are trapped and told by a general that they will be tried for treason and should show themselves to stop things getting worse. Another man says they definitely should – or they won’t be able to attend Homecoming… Um, what? It is revealed these fugitives are two teenage girls.

The story really begins two days earlier. At school, these two girls, Mae and Gabby, are sophomores but they are excelling in their academics, going to classes with the Seniors. They are seen as “nerds” who don’t fit in with the rest of their class. Mae spends time tutoring too, with one of those she tutors being Jaden, a jock who needs help in Math. Mae has a huge crush on Jaden, but Gabby continuously tells her that Jaden is not and will never be interested in someone like her, but Mae clings on to some hope that perhaps he does. Mae gets a text from Jaden, saying to meet him after football practice, which makes Mae wonder if he’s going to ask her to the Homecoming Dance. After all, he told her in tutoring that she ought to go to the dance… Gabby tells her that is not going to happen.

Popular girl Nevaeh approaches the two as they wait to see what Jaden wants to talk to Mae about. Nevaeh tells Mae that she will be going to Homecoming with Jaden because they’ve been going out for a whole 17 days! Jaden comes up to them after practice and says he was actually going to ask Mae for some extra help with his Math. Embarrassed, Mae tells them all that she already has a hot boyfriend, called Albert. He’s a genius, and sporty, and charitable, and just amazing. Nevaeh calls Mae’s bluff and says she wants to meet him. Mae and Gabby are picked up from school by Mae’s brother Bart. He says he saw Mae’s conversation with Nevaeh on the school’s website, humiliating Mae further.

That evening, Mae and Gabby discuss the fake boyfriend problem. Mae admits she’ll probably just have to tell the truth and say Albert was completely made-up. Gabby comes up with a better idea though: they’ll make Gabby a fake virtual boyfriend, using Mae’s father’s software from his video game company. It’s not like he works for the government.

Except it turns out Mae’s father actually does work for the US government, with the video game company being a cover. Mae’s father, Dr. James Hartley, has been working on the creation of a covert robotic operative, basically the perfect spy. He has just been given clearance to make this robot a reality.

Back at home, Gabby starts hacking into the software, known as X-17, causing all the technology at both Dr. Hartley’s laboratory and home office to switch on. Gabby gets Mae to answer the question prompts to build the boyfriend’s look and personality, covering areas like political allegiance, capabilities, personality, and even commander name. Once those have been answered, Gabby and Mae get their first look at “Albert”. A spark shocks them both from Gabby’s laptop screen, and the whole laboratory goes into overload as the “X-17” begins fabrication. Gabby says she can smell smoke, and thinks they may have fried some circuits. Going downstairs, the girls discover the mess is so much worse than that as all of Dr. Hartley’s home office equipment has been completely destroyed – and he’s on his way home! Gabby asks Mae’s brother Bart to stall him and keep him away from the office. Bart says he’ll only do that if Gabby agrees to be his date to the Homecoming dance. Under pressure, she says she will and goes about fixing the servers and equipment. When Bart and Mae’s father comes home, Bart distracts him with tea and jazz music, causing Dr. Hartley to fall asleep almost instantly. That buys them some time.

In the morning, Bart is left to continue fixing the equipment as Mae and Gabby head off to school. Dr. Hartley gets an urgent call from the lab and rushes over to work. At school, Nevaeh amusingly says that Mae’s boyfriend Albert added their classmates on social media last night, with Nevaeh obviously believing it was just Mae, having created a fake online profile for her fake boyfriend. As Mae is about to explain, Albert arrives to school in a bright orange Lamborghini, drawing everyone’s attention. Mae and Gabby are as shocked as everyone else at seeing that Albert is actually a real person!

At the lab, General McFee alerts Dr. Hartley to the fact this is a national emergency, as their robotic operative has gone. McFee thinks this was a hacking and a theft, and that they must find the X-17 and whoever took him. Unfortunately, the X-17 was built to be a covert spy, so no CCTV picks the robot up, neither leaving the room nor the building. The only piece of information they have is from a dogwalker who saw an attractive man leaving the building the night before – which isn’t much to go on.

Back at school, Albert is charming Mae and her classmates with his sensitivity, talent, and attractiveness. All except Gabby, who is annoyed that Mae is now spending all her time with Albert and ignoring her, as well as being very confused about why Albert is real. She believes he is an actor sent by the video game company to impersonate their virtual character and be a form of advertising, but Albert says he is very real – although his ability to read at lightning-fast speed would seem to suggest he is not exactly human, confusing Gabby further. Albert says he will kiss Mae at Homecoming, this being his mission. Bart calls Gabby to ask what is going on, since he’s seen pictures of Albert online and doesn’t like the idea of his little sister having an actual boyfriend.

Later, Albert is told to try out for football by the school’s coach who is impressed by his strength, endearing him to even more of the girls at school. Jaden is starting to feel a bit jealous of him though, especially as Mae forgets all about their tutoring session that afternoon to go to the park with Albert. Gabby also shows up at the park, not enjoying how nature is affecting her allergies, but she is soon told to leave Mae and Albert alone to talk. Fine, Gabby will just go and sneeze in a corner by herself then, yeah? Albert asks Mae to the Homecoming dance. She isn’t sure how to answer that and goes to talk to Gabby. Gabby tells Mae this wasn’t part of the plan, which was for them to graduate from school early and go to Harvard together, before becoming President and Vice President of the United States. Mae tells Gabby that wasn’t her plan, and says she likes Albert and having a boyfriend. Their conversation – or argument – is interrupted by Albert singing to Mae, drawing a crowd. They finish the song together, and Mae says she’ll go to Homecoming with Albert. Bart calls Gabby to say they need to get home now, because there is something very wrong with this situation. Gabby goes alone.

Meanwhile, at the lab, the government fear that the arms dealer group Black Sigma are behind the theft of the X-17 robot. They ask Dr. Hartley if the lab contains the only copy of the software. He tells them that actually there is a copy at his home office.

At the house, Black Sigma are scouting out the area, ready to go in. They are annoyed someone stole the X-17 before they could, so now they’ll have to find it. Also at the house, Gabby is told by Bart that, after fixing the computer, he learnt that Gabby has hacked into the Pentagon and tells her that his father works for the Department of Defense. Gabby is surprised that she managed to hack the Pentagon. On the computer, they find the manual for the X-17 robotic operative and this is where they learn that Albert is the X-17. At that moment, Black Sigma break into the office, so Bart and Gabby hide. Black Sigma take the X-17 files and destroy the servers. Government officials then arrive at the house and question Bart and Gabby. They pretend that they didn’t see anything and quickly make their excuses to leave the house. Black Sigma follow Bart and Gabby, hoping to be led to the X-17.

Gabby rushes to Mae and tells her she is the mission commander of Albert so is the only one who can shut Albert down. Mae refuses to do this, as she is now happy and popular, with her little group of fans wanting Gabby’s help with finding a perfect boyfriend too. Gabby tells Mae Albert is just a robot, but Mae ignores her, saying she loves him. At a loss what to do next, Gabby tells Bart that Mae wouldn’t let her explain the full story.

Albert has been tracked down by Black Sigma to the school and one of the men tries to attack Albert, but Albert fights him off and knocks him out. The other members of the group later find their guy in the storage room. They decide they need an electromagnetic pulse device to disable Albert.

Albert is put into the football game as the team are losing. He helps the team make a comeback with his insane speed and strength, simply running through opponents who cling on to Albert in the hopes of bringing him down. It doesn’t work. At the same time, the General is reporting the burglary at Dr. Hartley’s home to the police when one of them shows the General a video of the football game. The General sees that it is the X-17 playing. They go to the school.

As the game ends, Black Sigma use their device, and the Department of Defense arrive too to retrieve Albert. Albert is momentarily stunned by the pulse but makes an escape. The army’s arrival at the school causes everyone to scatter, with Gabby finally telling Mae everything she knows about Albert and what they’ve done. They go and hide. Nevaeh happens to overhear all this new information about Albert.

The government catch Black Sigma, but the X-17 is nowhere to be found, so they go after who stole him. The girls are tracked down, as per the opening scene. They are taken back to Dr. Hartley’s lab and are warned that what they’ve done could have had severe consequences for the world. However, they are told they are free to go as the General knows their intentions were nothing harmful. Mae asks where Albert is. The General says his system was temporarily taken down because of the electromagnetic pulse, but that he rebooted back to his default soldier mode, and is being tracked doing good all over the world. Mae is devastated that Albert won’t be with her anymore, but she believes he will come back for her, which frustrates Gabby who cannot get through to Mae.

At the Homecoming dance, Gabby arrives with Bart, and Jaden arrives with Nevaeh. He tries to talk to Mae, who arrives alone, but Nevaeh pulls him away. Suddenly, Mae sees a car pull up and who should come out of it but Albert. Dr. Hartley, who dropped Mae off at the dance, is also shocked but happy Mae gets to keep her date for Homecoming. But the General and the army arrive at the dance, knowing that this is where he would be. They plan to take the X-17 by force, but Dr. Hartley says if they let Albert finish his mission, which is to kiss Mae at the dance, then Albert will come peacefully. The General doesn’t want to do this, but when Dr. Hartley threatens to quit, the General reconsiders and orders everyone to prepare for “Operation Pucker Up”.

Inside, everyone is surprised to see Albert and Mae arrive together. Gabby tells Albert there is no way that he and Mae will ever be together, but he ignores her. Nevaeh and Jaden argue about how self-obsessed she is, and the two break up. As Homecoming Queen is announced, Mae is shocked to discover she was voted Homecoming Queen, which also horrifies Nevaeh who was sure it would be her. Dr. Hartley is so proud of his daughter – until he’s told by the General that they stuffed the ballot box to ensure she won! Nevaeh interrupts Mae’s Homecoming Queen speech and attempts to reveal Albert’s true identity. Instead, Jaden and others make out that Nevaeh is merely complimenting him, by calling him “dangerous” and a “machine”. She is ignored and the dance continues.

Jaden tells Bart and Gabby that he has spent too much time worrying about what people think. He admits he wanted to ask Mae to the dance but never had the guts to do so, and now she is with Albert. Gabby is annoyed at herself for always telling Mae that Jaden never liked her, when actually he did. She goes to find her and apologises for what she said about Jaden, saying she hasn’t been a very good friend to Mae recently, feeling like she’s been holding Mae back. The two reconcile.

Mae and Albert are given a slow dance together in front of everyone, which has been carefully manufactured with lights, rose petals, and a sparkly moon by the General to make sure this kiss happens. However, as Albert leans in, Mae pulls back, saying this isn’t how she wanted her first kiss to be because it is all too perfect and doesn’t feel real. Mae then sees that the army are all around them. Albert says he already knew but he had to make this the best night of Mae’s life. Now that it is over, he asks Mae to say the words. Mae tells him to initiate self-destruct. He says goodbye and his self-destruction begins, ripping a hole in the roof as he flies up and into the sky. To cover up the true reason for this, Bart tells everyone to appreciate the special effect display that the school put on for the dance!

The dance continues. Jaden talks to Mae and tells her that the line of smoke Albert left behind is a perfect logarithmic curve. He says he was never bad at Math and actually just liked spending time with his tutor. Jaden asks Mae to dance, but she says no, choosing to talk to Gabby instead. Mae tells Gabby she shouldn’t have let anything or anyone get in the way of their friendship, not even boys. Gabby then admits that she actually likes Mae’s brother. Mae takes this information quite well! The two dance the night away together.

CHARACTERS & CAST

Mae Hartley has spent much of her school life fully focused on academics, with the aim of graduating early and moving on to bigger and better opportunities. She is joined, or perhaps coaxed, into this journey by her best friend Gabby. However, Mae has started to think that they’ve missed out on the other social elements of high school, like having a large group of friends, and, of course, having boyfriends. Mae has a crush on football player Jaden, and really believes she has a chance with him. Since everyone, including her best friend, laughs at Mae for believing this, she makes up a whole fake boyfriend to cover her embarrassment, but when he miraculously comes to life, Mae turns out to be the one laughing. Albert, her new boyfriend, is as perfect as anyone can be. Although Mae likes Albert, and the newfound popularity his presence brings her, by the end of How to Build a Better Boy, Mae has realised that she’d much rather stick with her friend Gabby and actually try to find a boyfriend who may not be perfect but is at least real. That may’ve ended up being Jaden, but for now, Mae is trying to work out who she is and what she wants from life.

Kelli Berglund was cast as Mae, also starring as Bree Davenport in the Disney XD series Lab Rats (2012-16) at the time of filming How to Build a Better Boy. After her time on Disney, Berglund went on to appear as Madison in the movie Cherry (2021), starring Tom Holland, and appeared as Ren in Seasons 7 and 9 of the sitcom The Goldbergs (2013-23). She was also cast as Crystal Tyler in the Starz series Heels (2021-23) and more recently was cast as Nell Stewart in Queen of the Ring (2024).

Albert Banks is a robotic operative, officially known as X-17. Albert was meant to be a soldier, completing operations around the globe on behalf of the US government, however, when Mae and Gabby hack into the software, which they believe is just for a computer game company and would create them a virtual boyfriend, the X-17 comes to life as Albert, Mae’s perfect boyfriend. Albert is tall, blond, and athletic. He is sensitive, caring, and always knows the right thing to say. All the girls at school are jealous of Mae for having such a perfect boyfriend and they all want to find someone just like that. Albert also makes all the guys at school jealous, because they want to be as skilled a football player as him. Albert is devoted to Mae, and not embarrassed about showing his feelings one bit. Because of this, Mae instantly becomes attached to Albert, to the point she won’t listen to reason: that he is basically a robot spy and only cares about whatever he is programmed to care about; he doesn’t like Mae for her. But Mae was right to think he did actually like her, because Albert returns to school just to take her to Homecoming and to kiss her, which would complete his “mission”, despite the fact he knows the army are there to capture him. Albert even understands when Mae can’t go through with their kiss, and tells Mae to initiate his self-destruct so they can move on, showing Albert is the perfect boyfriend even in a break-up!

Marshall Williams was cast as Albert, going on to be cast in the recurring role of Spencer Porter in the final series of Glee (2009-15). Williams later appeared as Sam Tremblay in the first two seasons of the drama When Hope Calls (2019-present).

Gabby is Mae’s best friend; however, Gabby and Mae have differing opinions on one thing in particular: boys. Gabby doesn’t have time for boys. She just wants to graduate high school, go to Harvard, and then become the first female President of the United States, all with Mae by her side throughout, potentially even being her Vice President. Wow, how kind of you, Gabby! Gabby doesn’t think Mae should be thinking about boys like Jaden, but not wanting her friend to be embarrassed, and probably wanting to prove she can hack an IT system, Gabby helps Mae create her virtual boyfriend. Gabby never expected Albert to turn up as a real person though, nor did she expect Mae to become so obsessed with Albert that she ignores Gabby. Gabby discovers from Mae’s brother, Bart, that she accidentally hacked the Pentagon, not realising that they were building a robotic boyfriend, not a virtual one. But when Gabby tries to tell Mae the truth about this, Mae doesn’t listen, creating a major divide between the two. Eventually, this rift is healed at Homecoming as they both apologise for their behaviour, Gabby for not caring about Mae’s feelings for Jaden, and Mae for not listening to Gabby. It all works out in the end, and Gabby even starts to realise that boys aren’t so bad, after she starts dating Mae’s brother! The dynamic between Gabby and Mae reminded me a lot of Ben and Mandy’s friendship in Disney’s Prom Pact (2023), where the bossier friend, in this case Gabby, believes that their friend, in this case Mae, is happy with things being just the way they are, when in actual fact, they want something different.

Gabby Harrison was played by China Anne McClain. McClain’s acting career began at a young age when she chose to star as Jazmine Payne in Tyler Perry’s House of Payne (2007-present), a role which she returned to in 2020. McClain also starred alongside Cameron Boyce in the Adam Sandler films Grown Ups (2010) and Grown Ups 2 (2013). For Disney, McClain first appeared on the channel in the recurring role of Kiara in Jonas (2009-10), before securing a major role as Chyna Parks in the series A.N.T. Farm (2011-14), where she won the NAACP Image Award for Outstanding Performance in a Youth/Children’s Program. McClain was later cast as Freddie, daughter of Dr. Facilier, in the animated series Descendants: Wicked World (2015-17). When McClain was cast as Uma in Descendants 2 (2017), returning for the films that followed, her sister, Lauryn, took over this voice role. More recently, McClain was cast as Chantal Taylor in Adam Sandler’s Hubie Halloween (2020), and as Jennifer Pierce/Lightning in the superhero series Black Lightning (2018-21) on The CW. She also starred as Morgan Brewster in Brewster’s Millions: Christmas (2024), a Christmas-themed sequel to the 1985 comedy film Brewster’s Millions.

Mae’s brother Bart is immediately seen to be interested in Gabby, his sister’s best friend, although we are not sure how or why his feelings have evolved in this way. Bart shows Gabby that he likes her by basically blackmailing her to go to Homecoming with him; he says he’ll distract his father whilst Gabby and Mae attempt to fix all the technology in Dr. Hartley’s home office after they destroy it. Bart and Gabby do end up going to Homecoming, but not before they become united in their determination to stop Mae and Albert being together after learning he is an important weapon to the US government. Bart is actually quite panicky when he learns this fact, whereas Gabby takes this new information in her stride and is mostly just annoyed that Mae won’t listen to her, whereas Bart is clearly concerned about the consequences they’ll face when they are discovered to be the hackers… Well, Bart is just an accomplice to hacking, I guess, but I’m sure that’s still a criminal offence.

Matt Shively was cast as Bart Hartley, having previously starred as Ryan Laserbeam in the Nickelodeon series True Jackson, VP (2008-11) and voiced the character of Sky in the animated series Winx Club (2011-19) and its 2012 and 2013 movies. After Nickelodeon, and Disney, Shively later appeared as Damo in Power Rangers (2017); Larry in Father of the Year (2018); and Alex in The Wedding Year (2019). More recently, Shively starred as Quinten Mark Van Bryan in the sitcom Lopez vs Lopez (2022-25).

As with any teen comedy, although the “nerdy ones” might be the leads, there has to be some popular people to create conflict. In this case, we have the popular girl who is set to be Homecoming Queen, Nevaeh, whose name, as Albert points out, is “heaven” spelt backwards – although what the significance is of that, I don’t know; it’s not like she acts like an angel. Nevaeh is the one to alert the whole school to the fact that Mae has a crush on Jaden, something that would never be reciprocated, as everyone continues to tell Mae. Nevaeh calls Mae out on her fake boyfriend Albert, thinking Mae has just created an online profile, so she is very surprised when Albert turns out to be real – and she doesn’t like how much more popular Albert is than her own boyfriend, Jaden, or how much more popular Mae becomes by being with him. This makes Nevaeh jealous and wanting ammunition against Mae – and she finds it, because she overhears Gabby explaining who Albert is to Mae when the army gatecrash their football game. Nevaeh is then made even more angry when she loses out on Homecoming Queen to Mae so she attempts to warn everyone about the fact Albert is a robot, who could be dangerous. But nobody actually listens, as her speech is interrupted by Jaden. Jaden is the jock that Mae has been tutoring, but he is scared about what people would think if he dated a smart girl, so he keeps his mouth shut about his feelings and lets Nevaeh push him around. Eventually, Jaden stands up to Nevaeh and breaks up with her at Homecoming and then lets Mae know that he does like her, and actually only wanted to be tutored by her so he could spend time with her. Although Mae is clearly touched by this, she won’t let Jaden win her that easily. He’ll just have to try harder.

Nevaeh was played by Ashley Argota, who also played a character in Nickelodeon’s True Jackson, VP (2008-11), Lulu, before joining Kelli Berglund in Lab Rats (2012-16) with her role as Taylor. Argota was later cast as Lou Chan in the sitcom The Fosters (2013-18). Noah Centineo was cast as Jaden Stark, and his career has sky-rocketed since How to Build a Better Boy and his recurring role as Dallas on Disney’s Austin & Ally (2011-16). After this, Centineo went on to replace Jake T. Austin as Jesus Adams Foster in The Fosters (2013-18) from Season 3. He was then cast in a selection of Netflix romantic comedies, such as the To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before trilogy where he played Peter; Swiped (2018) being cast as Lance; and The Perfect Date (2019), starring as Brooks. He starred as Owen Hendricks in the Netflix series The Recruit (2022-25) and is set to play Ken Masters in Street Fighter, the 2026 movie adaptation of the video game series of the same name.

Alongside this main plot taking place at the school, the side plot involves Dr. Hartley and General McFee trying to work out who hacked into Dr. Hartley’s laboratory and stole the X-17 robotic operative. Obviously, this is important to the security of the US, and the General initially fears it is the arms dealer group Black Sigma who has done this. They are after the X-17 but they were not the culprits. Dr. Hartley and the General couldn’t have been more surprised that it was two silly teenage girls who did this, with one of them being Dr. Hartley’s daughter. General McFee is clearly mostly interested in getting the X-17 back in the hands of the US government, which is exactly what he should be doing, but Dr. Hartley is concerned about his daughter’s feelings after X-17, known to Mae and the others as Albert, is swiftly taken away from her. He doesn’t want Mae to be upset about this, which is why, when Albert does return to take Mae to Homecoming, he convinces the General to let Albert finish his mission, and then Albert will peacefully go with the army. So, the General sets about making this the most romantic Homecoming dance ever, except Albert tricks him and actually self-destructs on Mae’s order, leaving the General with nothing and Dr. Hartley with a feeling of pride that his daughter got one over on them! Dr. Hartley can always make another robot.

Ron Lea was cast as General McFee. Lea had previously been cast as Brian Malony in the Canadian legal drama Street Legal (1987-1994) and as Dr. Oliver Crane in the medical drama Doc (2001-04) which starred Billy Ray Cyrus. Around the time of How to Build a Better Boy, Lea was appearing as Gavin Hardcastle in the sci-fi thriller Orphan Black (2013-17). Dr. James Hartley was played by stage and screen actor Roger Bart. On stage, Bart won a Tony for his role as Snoopy in the 1999 production of You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown, before starring as both Carmen Ghia and Leo Bloom in various productions of The Producers in the 2000s. Recently, Bart originated the role of Dr. Emmett Brown in Back to the Future: The Musical, starring on the West End in London from 2021 to 2023, before moving over to Broadway from 2023 to 2025. On screen, Bart reprised his role as Carmen Ghia in the 2005 movie version of The Producers (2005) and appeared in the recurring role of George Williams in Desperate Housewives (2004-12). He was also cast as Mason Treadwell in Revenge (2011-15), and more recently, as Judge Wilson in Good Trouble (2019-24). Bart also provided the singing voice of Hercules in Disney Animation’s Hercules (1997) and played the role of Hades in the Off-Broadway 2019 stage production of the film at the Delacorte Theater in Central Park.

MUSIC

The soundtrack for How to Build a Better Boy contains a mixture of songs made famous by Disney Channel’s own singers and actors, as well as a selection of pop music.

From the Disney category, we have “Stand Out” performed by pop princess Sabrina Carpenter. At the time, Carpenter was starring on the channel in their series Girl Meets World (2014-17) as Maya Hart, alongside releasing music for Disney’s label Hollywood Records. She has since had various No. 1 singles like “Espresso”, “Please Please Please”, and “Nonsense”. Her song “Stand Out” is used for both the Opening and End Credits in How to Build a Better Boy. It was written by Carpenter, Rune Westberg, and Stevie Scott.

Following that we have a cover of Selena Gomez & the Scene’s 2011 song “Love You Like a Love Song” from their third and final album When the Sun Goes Down. In 2014, Gomez was no longer a fixture on Disney Channel screens, and she was releasing music as a solo artist. But the use of this song in How to Build a Better Boy shows how popular her music still was, especially amongst Disney Channel viewers. In the movie, “Love You Like a Love Song” is performed by Marshall Williams and Kelli Berglund, as Albert and Mae, during the sequence of them in the park after school. Albert begins singing alone with only a ukulele as accompaniment and is then joined by Mae to make it a duet. “Love You Like a Love Song” was written by Antonina Armato, Tim James, and Adam Schmalholz.

The final song used in How to Build a Better Boy to feature a Disney Channel star is “Something Real”. This is used for the final scene at Homecoming, and is performed by China Anne McClain and Kelli Berglund. It was written by Antonina Armato, Tim James, IN-Q, and Thomas Sturges. The song details Gabby and Mae’s journey throughout the movie, however, it is only used as background music, so they do not perform it in the film as their characters.

Outside of this, when Albert first arrives at school, much to the surprise of everyone, “Is That All You Got” by BossHouse is used. After that, we have the song that plays during the montage sequence of Mae and Albert at school together, where he plans a lunch date for her on the football field and frees the frogs that were meant to be used in Biology class. This song is “Higher”, by Scott Stallone, Steven Stern, Cristi Vaughan, Matt Todd Naylor, and David Wade. During the football game, the song playing as Albert outruns everyone on the field was not a song that I managed to find.  

For Mae and Albert’s slow dance at Homecoming, the song “Your Ways / I Love Your Ways” by Chuckie Perez is used. There were a few others at the dance that were more difficult to figure out. I believe one song briefly playing during this dance is “Come On Now” by Miss Amani. This is closely followed by “Today’s the Day”, performed by Michelle Lewis, as Mae is voted Homecoming Queen. The other two songs used at Homecoming I have not been able to work out, despite some lyrics being more audible than most background music.

The score for How to Build a Better Boy was composed by Kenneth Burgomaster, who has composed the score for numerous DCOMs, including Wizards of Waverly Place: The Movie (2009) and The Swap (2016). He also composed music for Disney Channel series like Dog with a Blog (2012-15) and A.N.T. Farm (2011-14). The full score has been uploaded as a playlist on Burgomaster’s official YouTube Channel.

PRODUCTION

Production on How to Build a Better Boy was announced in the summer of 2013, with filming completed between July and August of that year. Much of the cast was announced, alongside a brief plot, and a potential premiere date of 2014.

This new movie was seen to be a part of the Disney Channel’s changing of direction as some beloved shows like Shake It Up (2010-13) and Good Luck Charlie (2010-14) were coming to end, and new series like Girl Meets World (2014-17), I Didn’t Do It (2014-15), and Liv and Maddie (2013-17) were coming in, bringing in a new cast of Disney Channel stars[1].

The director was confirmed to be Paul Hoen, who has directed numerous Disney Channel Original Movies during his career, both musical and non-musical. In the non-musical category, some of his credits include directing Read It and Weep (2006), Eddie’s Million Dollar Cook-Off (2003), and The Luck of the Irish (2001). In the world of musicals, he directed Camp Rock 2: The Final Jam (2010), The Cheetah Girls: One World (2008), and the entire ZOMBIES movie franchise. Jason Mayland was the screenwriter for How to Build a Better Boy, having previously worked on the animated movie Space Chimps (2008) as well as writing episodes of the animated Disney Junior series Eureka! (2022-23).

How to Build a Better Boy was filmed in Toronto, Canada, with one specific location being the Ron Joyce football stadium at McMaster University campus, obviously used for the football game in the film. Filming took place at this location in early August 2013 for a few days. Production liked the McMaster name and their eagle logo so much that they sought permission to use it, and rewrote their script to make the movie’s school the fictional McMaster High School[2]. North Toronto Collegiate Institute was used for the high school.

There are elements of stunts in How to Build a Better Boy, to match Albert’s spy capabilities. Director Hoen worked together with stunt coordinator Branko Racki, who had previously worked on Pacific Rim (2013), Disney’s The Pacifier (2005), and Pompeii (2014) just to name a few, to work out some of these sequences. One of these includes a fight scene between Albert and a member of Black Sigma. To suit the teen movie genre, instead of this being an action-packed scene with lots of kicks and punches, it was lessened to include mostly blocking motions and no hits to the face.

Another difficult stunt sequence was the football game, which required Albert to run down the pitch at speed. Marshall Williams, who was cast as Albert, first read for the part of Jaden, but Hoen suggested he read for Albert instead, as they were struggling to find someone who fit the character. Williams had the physicality, was a football player, and a model. Hoen and Racki said Williams was a good athlete and very capable with his stunts, although stunt doubles were also used. The shot of Albert having four or five players clinging on to him was not actually done as it appears, with some “movie magic” achieving this. Players actually ran at a padded vehicle as it moved down the field, with camera trickery, CGI, and editing producing the final shot[3].

RECEPTION

How to Build a Better Boy premiered in the US on Disney Channel on 15th August 2014, with the movie being promoted on the channel throughout Summer 2014.

This movie followed Cloud 9, which premiered in January 2014 and starred Dove Cameron from Liv and Maddie (2013-17), and Zapped, which was led by Zendaya and premiered in June 2014, bridging the gap between her role as Rocky in Shake It Up (2010-13) and her leading role as K.C. Cooper in K.C. Undercover (2015-18).

How to Build a Better Boy attracted an average of 4.6 million viewers on its premiere date, this being the most-watched program of the day for kids 2-11, and tweens 9-14. It also generated over 1 million views over seven days on the WATCH Disney Channel app. The overall viewing figures for How to Build a Better Boy were lower than those of either Cloud 9 or Zapped, however, only marginally. Cloud 9 had an average of 5 million on its premiere, and Zapped had 5.7 million. Anything from 4 to 6 million was standard for Disney Channel in the 2010s. With their three DCOMs of 2014, Disney Channel aired three of the year’s six most-watched original television movies[4].

Some viewers enjoyed How to Build a Better Boy for its message about self-acceptance and not conforming. High schoolers find it particularly difficult to stand out from the crowd and not give in to peer pressure, so to see Gabby be comfortable with her intellect, and Mae happy to wait for the right guy to come in to her life, was seen as a positive move from Disney. Many also praised the performances by China Anne McClain and Kelli Berglund; I enjoyed watching their friendship evolve and change during the movie.

However, there were some comments around the unrealistic elements of the movie, such as the US government not punishing the girls for as serious an offence as hacking is. Although How to Build a Better Boy perhaps doesn’t comment enough on the severity of hacking, in a time where we have an increased number of cyber-attacks happening in the world, sometimes from teenagers, I’d say the whole concept of this movie is pretty unrealistic and leans towards science-fiction so it’s not really fair to comment on its realism! Others felt that the battle between nerdy and popular girls was also an overused theme in teen movies.

But the complaint that came up the most was that many have said How to Build a Better Boy is basically a gender-swapped version of the 1980s John Hughes teen comedy Weird Science (1985), so they claim Disney Channel ripped off this film. The overall storyline is very similar; that two teenage boys who are outcasts at school create what they think will be a virtual perfect woman but she accidentally comes to life after they hack into a government computer system. Weird Science is less “family-friendly” than How to Build a Better Boy and Disney’s version is about teenage girls, because it’s much more acceptable in this day and age to have two teenage girls make themselves a perfect boyfriend, instead of two teenage boys making their dream woman. Hypocritical or not, you decide.

For me, since I haven’t seen Weird Science, How to Build a Better Boy was very similar to an episode of Sabrina, the Teenage Witch (1996-2003), the Season 1 episode “Dream Date”, where Sabrina’s aunts make her a date to her school dance out of “Man Dough”. Chad Corey Dylan is made to be a great dancer, a daredevil, a musician, and seriously enthusiastic, although one of his arms is shorter than the other. But his perfection can’t match up to Sabrina’s true love for Harvey Kinkle. This is like Mae accepting that, although Albert is great, she’d be happier with someone more real.

How to Build a Better Boy might not have been the most original concept, but it was seen to be enjoyable, although not amazing, by the general Disney Channel viewership. Plus, it was still nominated for a couple of awards. One was at the NAACP Image Awards, where China Anne McClain was nominated for her role as Gabby in the category of Outstanding Performance by a Youth in a Youth/Children’s Program, but lost out to the voice of Dora the Explorer, Fatima Ptacek, in Nickelodeon’s Dora and Friends: Into the City! (2014-17). Paul Hoen was also nominated at the Directors Guild of America Awards for his directing of How to Build a Better Boy but he lost out to Jonathan Judge, the director of the pilot episode of Nickelodeon’s 100 Things to Do Before High School (2014-16).

LEGACY

There was no sequel to How to Build a Better Boy, although China Anne McClain and Kelli Berglund did continue to appear in Disney series and movies after its air date.

You could consider Bad Hair Day (2015) as following in the footsteps of How to Build a Better Boy, by having two main story points. One is about high school life, so for How to Build a Better Boy it’s about boyfriends as well as Homecoming, and for Bad Hair Day it’s about prom, and a second storyline where the leads are being chased for unknowingly contributing to criminal activity. For How to Build a Better Boy, the army and the government want their X-17 back in their possession and away from groups like Black Sigma, and in Bad Hair Day, the two leads try to stop diamond thief Pierce from escaping the authorities. From my point of view though, How to Build a Better Boy balanced these two differing movie themes the best; Bad Hair Day felt very random at times as it switched between the two.

Disney Channel Original Movies explored numerous different genres across the 2000s and 2010s, so How to Build a Better Boy continued in that experimental nature. However, it has to be said that DCOMs are now reverting back to their favoured slate of sequels and musicals once again. More unique films don’t seem to be getting a look-in at the moment, as we have a fifth Descendants film, a third Camp Rock film, and potentially a fifth ZOMBIES film listed as the channel’s upcoming movies. 

FINAL THOUGHTS

How to Build a Better Boy did what Disney Channel tend to do with its movies. They made a tween and teen-friendly flick featuring two of the channel’s stars, one from one series, and one from a different series. Combined, they brought in their own fans.

The 2010s on Disney Channel were made for a different generation to my generation of watchers from the 2000s, but the series and movies of the 2010s proved that Disney were still very capable of making television movies, even if they were zanier than the DCOMs of the 2000s. How to Build a Better Boy was a different type of film compared to High School Musical, Camp Rock, and The Cheetah Girls, for example.

But those who grew up around that time probably like How to Build a Better Boy for that reason. How to Build a Better Boy may not have been particularly original, but it had humour, it tackled high school anxieties, and once again, Disney Channel showed they could make stars, showcasing the talented actors they’ve become well-known for casting.


REFERENCES

[1] Credit: Philiana Ng, ‘‘A.N.T. Farm’, ‘Lab Rats’ Stars to Topline Disney Channel TV Movie’, HollywoodReporter.com, 31st July 2013.

[2] Credit: Jemma Wolfe, ‘Disney Channel filming teen movie on Mac campus’, TheSil.ca, 8th August 2013.

[3] Credit: LA 411 Blog, ‘“How To Build A Better Boy” – Creating Stunts with Director Paul Hoen and Stunt Coordinator Branko Racki’, LA411.com, 15th August 2014.

[4] Credit: Rick Kissell, ‘‘How to Build a Better Boy’ Draws 4.6 Million for Disney Channel on Friday Night’, Variety.com, 18th August 2014.

Geek Charming (2011)

  1. BACKGROUND
  2. PLOT
  3. CHARACTERS & CAST
  4. MUSIC
  5. PRODUCTION
  6. RECEPTION
  7. LEGACY
  8. FINAL THOUGHTS
  9. REFERENCES

BACKGROUND

How many high school movies base their whole story around prom, or someone wanting to be Prom Queen? I’ll give you a hint: A LOT.

Disney Channel’s Geek Charming is no different, although instead of wanting to be Prom Queen, the main character wants to be Blossom Queen, seemingly the springtime equivalent. It’s either completely different or exactly the same, depending on how cynical you are. Regardless, we’re supposed to think that being Blossom Queen is super important.

I’m very cynical about prom and that’s probably got something to do with the fact I’m British and prom here is not the same as prom in the US, so this emphasis on how exciting prom is and how crucial it is to be crowned Prom Queen means very little to me. I was also not one of the popular girls at school so I would’ve had little to no chance of being voted Prom Queen even if it had been a thing at my school.

Maybe all this combined is why I didn’t like Geek Charming. The whole story revolves around “Queen Bee” Dylan’s drive to become Blossom Queen but when she invites a “geeky” boy into her social circle, she slowly changes and becomes unpopular. That sounds like a very tame version of Mean Girls (2004), doesn’t it? Perhaps more like Mean Girls 2 (2011), its sequel that was led by Disney Channel stars and lacked all the bite of the original.

That’s how I felt watching Geek Charming. This wasn’t even the first time I’d watched it. I didn’t watch it the year it was released, because I was drifting away from Disney Channel around that time, but I watched it a few years later on Disney Life, that UK and Europe streaming app that turned out to be a precursor to Disney+. I don’t remember liking the film, but I didn’t think I hated it. That just shows how much things can change over the years, because I actually really didn’t like Geek Charming and couldn’t wait for it to be over.

It dragged on and on, taking ages to get to an ending we’d already managed to play out in our heads before it was confirmed on screen. The story was predictable, the characters were not particularly likeable – I didn’t even manage to figure out the names of most of the minor characters – and I didn’t laugh once, not even out of awkwardness or embarrassment, as I have watching plenty of other DCOMs I didn’t like. This movie didn’t make me feel much at all to be perfectly honest. I understand that Geek Charming is not aimed at adults, and I could see it trying to have a deeper meaning to it, by giving Dylan a less shallow side to her, but that wasn’t enough for me to get on board with it.

PLOT

Dylan is a popular teenage girl, who is dreaming of becoming her school’s Blossom Queen, so much so she is literally daydreaming about that moment of winning the crown when we first meet her.

We then find that Dylan is at school, being asked if she would like to sign up to run for Blossom Queen. She most definitely does and adds her name to the list. Dylan and her two friends, Hannah and Lola, head to the lunchroom where they survey the area, although they know exactly where they’ll be sitting: up on a ramp with all the other populars, so they can literally feel mightier than the lowly crowd below them. Dylan spots her closest competition for Blossom Queen – Nicole, a cheerleader – on her way to her table.

But as Dylan and her friends discuss this, some “geek” spills his lunch all over Dylan – how dare he! Dylan proceeds to scream at him in front of everyone, with this “geek”, Josh, struggling to defend himself. The movie cuts to show Josh and Dylan talking about how they reacted to this incident. These little cuts happen quite frequently; it’ll all make sense at the end. We then see what really happened. Josh was walking behind Dylan and her friends with his lunch tray when Dylan sprayed her perfume all around herself, with some getting into Josh’s eyes, causing him to bump in to them, so it was all an accident. Dylan storms off to her table.

Josh meets up with his three friends, who are all part of Film Club, and Josh is their president. Josh starts to wonder about the world of the populars, but is quickly distracted by his crush, cool girl Amy, walking past. His friends tell him Amy is way out of Josh’s league. Josh basically agrees with this and turns the conversation to a film competition Josh wants to enter so he can win a spot at Hollywood Film Camp. Josh goes to his teacher, Mr. F, with his initial idea: to make a documentary on robot voices. Mr. F doesn’t think this is challenging enough and thinks Josh should do a documentary on something human.

Later that day, Dylan is with her dad, a real estate owner, at the mall where he is talking about a potential new store. Dylan waits for a gap in the conversation to ask if she can have some help with marketing for her Blossom Queen campaign. Her father refuses to do this and rushes off to a meeting. Dylan talks to her friends instead, but soon drops her very expensive handbag in the mall fountain. Dylan cries for security to turn off the fountain and retrieve it, but nobody cares enough to listen. You know, First World problems and all that. Luckily, Josh was working at a phone store nearby and hears the commotion. Josh comes to the rescue by striding into the fountain and returning Dylan’s bag to her. Dylan takes it and walks away without even a “thank you”, leading Josh to go after her. Josh snatches “Mr. Sanchez” back – yes, Dylan names her bags – and asks for a favour instead. He pitches the idea of Dylan starring in his documentary film which will be all about popularity. Dylan decides that if this film is good, it’ll be even better publicity for her Blossom Queen campaign than anything Nicole cab come up with, so she agrees – with some strict rules, for example, Josh can only be around her during filming times. Nice.

At home, we learn that, although Dylan lives in a big, fancy house, her life is very lonely. It’s even worse today because their housekeeper, Marta, is out at the dentist. Dylan throws her soaked handbag into the dryer and eats her dinner alone, before going to her room. In her room, she looks at a photo of herself and Amy. It turns out those two used to be best friends before high school. It’s also revealed that Dylan’s mum has died, as we see Dylan look over some of her old things, including a dress. In contrast, Josh comes home to a loving dog and a doting mother, who might have some wacky culinary skills but is there for him nonetheless. Josh tells his mother about his new documentary and how the subject will be popular girl Dylan. She is excited for him. Mr. F also approves the idea so it goes ahead.

The next day at school, Josh sits with Dylan and her friends at lunch, up on that ramp, though his way to the table is almost blocked by jocks who don’t understand why a geek would be sitting in their sacred area. Josh begins filming. Dylan tells the camera that being popular is not easy, and that she has a lot of things she has to keep up with, like making sure she’s looking pretty and fashionable at all times, as well as doing “charity work”, which, for Dylan, involves helping tragic “fashion victims”. Dylan introduces her boyfriend, Asher, who is a volleyball player. Dylan adores Asher, but he doesn’t seem all that in to her…

After school, Josh continues filming Dylan as she goes shopping, which is crucial to helping the country’s economy, of course! Dylan trashes cheerleader Nicole on camera too, saying how she is only “cheerleader popular”, whatever that means. She later trashes her friends, Lola and Hannah, saying that her popularity is contagious and that is why they hang out with her, in the hope that some of that popularity will rub off on them. When Dylan goes into the changing rooms, Josh takes the opportunity to talk to Lola and Hannah about Dylan. They tell Josh that Asher only likes Dylan because she worships him and that Dylan is a total drama queen. I’m pretty sure Josh had already worked that one out for himself! As they leave the store and head to a diner, Dylan is asked what her life goals are. She says becoming Blossom Queen is her only goal because if she doesn’t achieve that, then her life is over. She also talks about how people have to stay in their correct social circles and cannot mix outside of them, otherwise terrible misunderstandings could happen, like how Josh might think that he can ask Dylan out just because he is hanging out with her, leading to potential embarrassment for him. Wow.

Josh reviews his footage that evening and tells his mum how he is struggling to get anything deeper from Dylan, believing her to just be as shallow as she appears. Josh’s mum tells him that probably isn’t the case and the only way to get Dylan to reveal her true self is to dig deeper, like all good filmmakers do.

The next day, Josh is invited to film Dylan at a beach party. Josh brings along his Film Club friends, Steven and Ari, to help with the documentary, by shooting some “B-roll”. Josh sees Amy litter-picking around the beach and stars to talk to her, but Dylan sees the attention is not being focused on her and throws a ball at Josh, telling him to return to her so they can get back to the documentary. Dylan talks about Amy with Josh, saying how she isn’t popular enough for Dylan to hang out with anymore. Asher’s volleyball team, although losing initially causing Asher to be rude and moody with Dylan, end up winning their match and announce they are going out to get pizza, despite the fact Dylan has already booked for everyone to go to a sushi restaurant. Nobody wants sushi so they all leave to get pizza.

As Dylan heads back to her car, she sees it is being towed for unpaid driving tickets. Josh says he’ll give her a ride home. Dylan doesn’t want to get into his old, rundown car but has little choice, however, as they try to leave, Josh finds his car battery is dead and they’ll need to walk to a gas station. Josh tells Dylan she’s welcome to wait in the car but she doesn’t want to be seen by anyone in his car, so she walks with Josh. On the way though, Dylan hurts her ankle and makes Josh carry her. They then get into an argument as Josh calls Dylan a diva. Josh quits the documentary, as does Dylan.

Josh talks to his teacher back at school, wanting to change his documentary subject but he is told it is too late to change subject. Also at school, Dylan is canvassing for votes to be Blossom Queen but her speech is interrupted by Nicole who starts doing cheers and handing out free cupcakes. This seems to work as girls who Dylan was sure would vote for her now seem to be planning on voting for Nicole. Dylan realises she needs Josh’s documentary or she has no chance of winning. Dylan finds a leaflet for a Film Night in the bag of one of Josh’s friends, Caitlin. She decides to go there and apologise to Josh.

At the movie, Dylan surprises Josh by making an appearance. She pretends to like science-fiction films and shocks Josh and his friends by actually liking the movie they watched and even has some smart comments about it. Dylan is about to catch the bus home, since she still doesn’t have her car, but Josh says he can drive her home. They talk about restarting filming on the documentary since they both need each other. Josh agrees as long as Dylan stops acting like a diva.

Josh is invited into Dylan’s house and he learns that Dylan’s mum died and the real reason Dylan wants to be Blossom Queen so badly is because her mum was one too. Josh says his dad lives in San Diego so he kind of understands what it’s like to not have a parent around. Dylan decides to show Josh how to make the best ice-cream sundae and they mess around making those. Talk soon turns to each other’s love lives, with both of them disapproving of the others choices. Dylan changes the subject by saying she thinks Josh needs a makeover. He agrees to her plan. They go out shopping and to the salon, and turn Josh into a cooler version of himself. Josh takes Dylan to his house for dinner where his mother believes the two of them are dating. Dylan says they are not, although she thinks Josh is a good guy, but she has a boyfriend.

Dylan walks to school with Josh the next day so he can debut his new look. The girls all seem to love it, although Josh’s friends don’t like who is becoming. He continues to ditch his friends to eat lunch with Dylan and the populars, creating a divide between them. Dylan spending so much time with Josh is irritating her friends and Asher too. Dylan convinces Josh to ask Amy out on a date, proving that Dylan does not have a crush on Josh, nor does he on her, like everyone thinks. Amy agrees to a date on Saturday.

At work that day, Josh meets Dylan’s father who invites him to dinner at their house as he also believes the two of them are dating. Dylan comes home to find her father watching sci-fi films and eating junk food with Josh. They again reiterate that they are not together. Dylan’s dad is a bit disappointed as he likes Josh much better than Asher, and Dylan is much more herself around Josh as is proven by her competing in a burping contest with both of them, something Josh caught on camera, along with other silly antics. A rough cut of Josh’s documentary is needed soon but is progressing well.

On Saturday, Josh tries to figure out where to take Amy but it turns out they don’t have much in common. Josh takes her to Asher’s party, where Dylan suggested they went. At the party, Amy tries to get Josh to dance with her but he seems more interested in spending time with Dylan so she tells him to talk to her. Dylan, meanwhile, is upset after Nicole calls her a loser, believing she’ll lose out on Blossom Queen. Josh finds Dylan sat alone and they talk about Amy. It turns out Dylan ditched Amy when they were younger, believing Dylan would forever be in Amy’s shadow. Dylan then tells Josh he needs to flirt with Amy, and starts to show him how to do that. Who should come in and see them both sat so close together but Asher and Amy. Dylan rushes after Asher, and Josh leaves with Amy. He asks her to the dance but Amy says no, since it’s quite clear he likes Dylan.

The next day, Dylan oversleeps and loses a contact lens. She decides to try her luck at school without wearing her glasses, because they’re so uncool, but when she gets a note from Asher, she puts her glasses on to read it, shocking her friends. It’s a note breaking up with her. Asher tells Dylan she’s changed and should just go to the dance with Josh. Dylan tries to talk to Josh at lunch but he has a strict film deadline to meet so he says he can’t spend time with her right now. Josh goes back to sitting with his friends who tell him that they voted in Caitlin as Film Club President because Josh hadn’t had time for them. Dylan also learns she has lost her seat at the cool table. To make things worse, Dylan sees Lola and Hannah shopping for the dance without her after school. They tell her they didn’t invite her because she’s always with Josh. Dylan goes home and has a quiet dinner with her father and his girlfriend. She believes that Josh’s film will be worth all this.

At the Film Festival, the whole school, including Dylan, is there to watch Josh’s movie, titled “The Popularity Project”. Dylan starts watching and is horrified to learn that Josh has made her look like a mean, bitchy bimbo and everyone is laughing at her. Dylan walks out before the movie ends. Josh goes after her but Dylan is too annoyed at him to listen. She hates her old self and all he has done is embarrass her in front of everyone.

Amy, who did watch the whole film, goes to Dylan’s house the next day with a DVD of the film. She tells Dylan to watch it all, to understand what Josh was trying to do. It turns out everyone loved seeing the vulnerable, smart, goofy side of Dylan. Dylan apologises to Amy for ignoring her for all these years. Amy says she understands and that even though Dylan stopped being her friend, Amy didn’t stop being hers.

At Spring Formal, Dylan shows up wearing her mother’s dress. All her old friends, like Hannah, Lola, and Asher, who dropped her so quickly just a couple of days ago, are now desperate to be her friend again after Josh’s documentary turned out to be a hit. Blossom Queen is soon announced and Dylan has won it. She makes a speech talking about how it’s better to be yourself and not to change to please others. Dylan appreciates having true friends, like Amy and Josh now. Dylan then finds Josh and apologises to him for what she said about his movie. She actually really liked it and appreciated it. The two kiss and dance together, becoming an official couple.

The end of the movie shows Dylan and Josh talking to the camera, saying how that was the story of how the “princess” and the “film geek” met. So, now all the weird reaction cuts make sense; this whole film was meant to be a documentary. Josh and Dylan apologise for the names they called each other, and the two walk off together.

CHARACTERS & CAST

Dylan initially comes across as a snobby, entitlement little rich girl at the start of Geek Charming. All she cares about is being popular and pretty, so that she can become Blossom Queen at her school’s Spring Formal. She has her two sidekicks, Lola and Hannah, and her jock boyfriend Asher to complete the cliché. Dylan is completely self-centred and quite bitchy to those she feels are lesser than her – which is pretty much everyone, even her two friends. Gradually, we learn that this is just a façade that Dylan has put on because she never felt her actual self would get anywhere in life. Dylan is actually intelligent, thoughtful, and has her geeky moments, like everyone. She also lost her mother at a young age, and the only reason she wants to be Blossom Queen is because it’ll make her feel closer to her. I wish she had a different way of feeling closer to her mother which wasn’t about winning a popularity contest, like trying to get into the same college as her mum or something; that might’ve made me feel some empathy towards Dylan. The message of the movie just doesn’t work with this goal, because Dylan figured out that having true friends is better than being popular by winning a contest that’s all about who is the most popular! It would have been better for Dylan not to win Blossom Queen, so she could learn you don’t always get what you want. Although Dylan as a character has grown by the end of the movie, I still find her difficult to understand and like.  

Sarah Hyland was cast as Dylan. She is most known for her role as Haley Dunphy in the ABC sitcom Modern Family (2009-20). She has also had roles in romantic comedy films, like playing Ava in Date and Switch (2014); Mara in The Wedding Year (2019); and Kelly in My Fake Boyfriend (2022), which also starred Disney Channel alum Dylan Sprouse. More recently, Hyland appeared as Heidi in Peacock’s Pitch Perfect: Bumper in Berlin (2022), a spin-off to the film series, and is currently starring as Daisy Buchanan in The Great Gatsby on Broadway, alongside Ryan McCartan from Disney Channel’s Liv and Maddie (2013-17).

Then we have “geek” Josh. Josh’s first encounter with Dylan in this movie is when he spills his lunch over her. It isn’t actually his fault; it is Dylan’s erratic perfume spraying that caused it, but Dylan certainly makes him suffer, by screaming at him in the middle of the cafeteria. Josh doesn’t care though. He doesn’t even like Dylan. He has his Film Club friends and his crush on Amy. Josh is only focused on making his documentary, so he can achieve his dream of making movies on Hollywood. Josh later manages to convince Dylan to show her true self, which helps her self-confidence and proves to be more likeable than her diva routine, but his documentary could be seen as being a bit exploitative and mean-spirited, especially as he films Dylan burping, which doesn’t seem like something most girls would want broadcast to the world, or worse, their whole school.

Josh was played by Matt Prokop. He guest starred in some episodes of Disney Channel series, such as Hannah Montana (2006-11) and Good Luck Charlie (2010-14), but is best known for his role as Jimmie “Rocket Man” Zara in High School Musical 3: Senior Year (2008).

Dylan’s “friends” are Hannah and Lola, who, according to Dylan, hang out with her in the hopes that they might become popular. It’s quite clear Hannah and Lola don’t like Dylan, as they talk about her behind her back to Josh and his camera. Dylan orders them about all the time, so I don’t really blame them, but if they had some self-respect and didn’t care about being popular, then they would’ve ditched her, so it’s kind of their own fault. They also aren’t nice people either since they do ditch Dylan, but only after they’ve decided she’s “uncool” for spending so much time with Josh.  Hannah and Lola then try to suck up to Dylan once again at the Spring Formal as they discover that Dylan is popular once again – only to find that Dylan doesn’t want their fake friendship anymore. That’s karma for you.

Hannah was played by Vanessa Morgan, who was cast in the role of Marion in the Disney Channel-affiliated movie Harriet the Spy: Blog Wars (2010). She had previously appeared in the teen sitcom The Latest Buzz (2007-10) as Amanda Pierce, going on to star as Sarah in the 2010 movie My Babysitter’s a Vampire, and its subsequent series, which ran from 2011 to 2012. More recently, Morgan was cast in the role of Toni Topaz in Riverdale (2017-23) and stars as Max Mitchell in the Canadian series Wild Cards (2024-present). Lola was played by Lili Simmons, who went on to appear as Rebecca Bowman in the action series Banshee (2013-16), and Lila Stanton in the horror series The Purge (2018-19). More recently, she starred as Claudia Flynn in the Starz series Power Book IV: Force (2022-25).

For Josh’s friends, there are three in his Film Club: Ari, Steven, and Caitlin. We don’t get to see too much of Josh’s friends in the film and they aren’t overly important to the story, apart from them being annoyed at how much time Josh is spending with Dylan instead of them. Caitlin was probably the more interesting of the characters, since she had a crush on Josh, but this was resolved quickly at the end of the film with Caitlin choosing to dance with Steven, the more “uncool” of the three, who is a bit clumsy and acts and speaks without thinking first. Ari is the more serious one of the group, and is very focused.

Kacey Rohl was cast as Caitlin. Rohl went on to appear in the recurring roles of Abigail Hobbs in Hannibal (2013-15) and Marina Andrieski in the Syfy series The Magicians (2015-20). She was also cast as Alena Whitlock in Arrow (2012-20) from Season 5 to Season 7. Steven was played by Jimmy Bellinger, who later appeared in the recurring roles of Edwin in the ABC sitcom The Middle (2009-18), and Artie Smalls in Disney Channel’s Liv and Maddie (2013-17). Recently, he was cast as Mason in Not Dead Yet (2023-24). Ari was played by David Del Rio, who was cast as Manny in A California Christmas (2020) and its 2021 sequel A California Christmas: City Lights for Netflix. He currently stars as Billy Martinez in Matlock (2024-present).

Josh’s crush, Amy, is a former best friend of Dylan’s. Amy is a musician in a band, and is kind to everyone. She doesn’t seem to believe in labels or popularity, talking to anyone who wants to talk to her, including Josh. Though Dylan does help Josh pluck up the courage to ask Amy on a date after giving him a makeover, I don’t think the makeover had anything to do with Amy saying yes to this date; she probably would’ve said yes anyway because she seems to like talking to Josh. Amy later proves to be a good friend to Dylan when she explains how Josh’s documentary hasn’t ruined Dylan’s life. Dylan showed no kindness to Amy for years, and yet, Amy decided she should continue to be a friend to her.

Amy was played by Sasha Pieterse, who was best known for her role as Alison DiLaurentis in Pretty Little Liars (2010-17) at the time of Geek Charming’s release. Pieterse reprised her role in the short-lived spin-off Pretty Little Liars: The Perfectionists (2019). Prior to Geek Charming, she appeared in the recurring role of Amanda Strazzulla in Season 4 of Heroes (2006-10). In recent years, she was cast in the dual role of Anna and Zoe in the thriller film The Image of You (2024).

Finally, let’s talk about the mean characters in Geek Charming. One of these is Asher, Dylan’s boyfriend, then ex, who was never much of a boyfriend to Dylan, only taking her praise and affection and never giving any in return. Dylan is shocked when Asher breaks up with her for spending time with Josh, but it was for the best. Asher is a complete jerk. Jordan Nichols was cast in this role, having previously guest starred in a few episodes of the Disney Channel series Shake It Up (2010-13) and Good Luck Charlie (2010-14). He also appeared in a few episodes of Supah Ninjas (2011-13) for Nickelodeon.

The other mean character to mention is Nicole, a cheerleader and Dylan’s toughest competition for Blossom Queen. She clearly despises Dylan, calling her a loser at Asher’s party and interrupts Dylan’s campaign trail with her free cupcakes, essentially buying votes, but hey, all’s fair in love and high school popularity contests! She also later goes out with Asher after he dumps Dylan. Nicole was played by Andrea Brooks, who went on to be cast as Eve Teschmacher in the superhero series Supergirl (2015-21). Brooks is currently playing Faith Carter in the drama series When Calls the Heart (2014-present).

MUSIC

Geek Charming’s soundtrack features a mix of music styles.

During the montage of Dylan making over Josh, the song “Hey, Princess” performed by Allstar Weekend is played. It’s an upbeat song that is relatively catchy. The song was written by Zachary Porter, Nathan Darmody, Sam Hollander, and Dave Katz and was originally released as part of Allstar Weekend’s debut extended play Suddenly in 2010.

After Dylan gives her speech as Blossom Queen, the song playing is “Words” by indie rock band Doves. This song then plays throughout the ending of the film, all the way to the End Credits. It is a pleasant piece of music to wrap up the movie. “Words” was part of the Doves’ album The Last Broadcast, released in 2002. The song was written by band members Jimi Goodwin, Andy Williams, and Jez Williams.

There are some excerpts of classical music that appear in Geek Charming too. One is “The William Tell Overture”, composed by Rossini, which is used for the life-or-death situation where Dylan’s handbag has fallen into the mall fountain and Josh gallantly wades in to the water to retrieve it for her. I’m assuming this music was used as a contrast between the expressiveness of the music, and the comical rescue of the purse.

Another use of classical music is “Ride of the Valkyries” by Richard Wagner, which is used as the soundtrack for the in-movie film that precedes Josh’s at the Film Competition. The movie is about a vicious hamster so I guess that music works with that idea!  

Those are the most obvious songs within the film, but there are a few others, used mostly for background noise. One that I managed to work out was the song “Come On Now” by Miss Anami, which is the second song heard at Asher’s party. But despite having audible lyrics, I’ve been unable to figure out what is the first song playing, when Amy and Josh first arrive. This was a similar problem I had to the song that is playing when Dylan is home alone early on in the film, and the first song at Spring Formal. None of these songs are credited in the End Credits of the movie. Online, some sites claim to have found songs matching these scenes, however, I don’t believe they do match.

Nathan Wang is credited as the composer for the score of Geek Charming. Wang composed the music for other DCOMs including Hatching Pete (2009); Wendy Wu: Homecoming Warrior (2006); and Christmas…Again? (2021), amongst many other non-Disney projects.

PRODUCTION

Geek Charming is another case of a Disney Channel Original Movie being based on a book.

This book is the young adult novel Geek Charming by Robin Palmer, published in 2009. I have not read the book and there isn’t a huge amount of information online comparing the movie and the book’s plot and story; however, it would appear that one major change is that the book appears to be set in Los Angeles, however, the DCOM is supposedly set in Seattle, Washington. The school’s name is different as well, changing from the novel’s Castle Heights High, to Woodlands Academy[1].

Although Geek Charming the film is said to be set in Washington, it was actually filmed in Vancouver, Canada, as so many productions seem to be, especially Disney ones. Some specific filming locations include a house on Celtic Avenue in Southland, Vancouver, used as Dylan’s house, and Aberdeen Centre in Richmond, Vancouver being the location of the mall with that fountain that Dylan’s poor designer handbag ended up. The beach scene was filmed at Kitsilano Beach in Vancouver.

Another story change is that the character of Amy was quite different between the novel and the film. In the book, Amy and Dylan apparently stopped being friends as Amy started dating a boy that Dylan had a crush on. Amy does still prove herself to be a good friend to Dylan by helping her deal with the fallout from Josh’s documentary, but instead of Amy accepting that Dylan and Josh should be together, Amy goes to the dance with Josh and those two are dating by the end of the book[2].

Apparently, Robin Palmer, author of Geek Charming, wanted nothing to do with the production of Disney Channel’s Geek Charming and didn’t even read the script. Of course, Palmer was still credited in the Opening Credits though.

Elizabeth Hackett and Hilary Galanoy adapted Palmer’s novel for the screen. The two continued to collaborate on the screenplays for other movies after Geek Charming, including the Netflix movies La Dolce Villa (2025) and Falling Inn Love (2019).

Jeffrey Hornaday directed Geek Charming. Hornaday is both a director and choreographer. His choreography credits include the Disney Parks attraction Captain EO, a 3D short film which starred Michael Jackson; the 1983 movie Flashdance; and the 1985 film adaptation of the musical A Chorus Line. After Geek Charming, Hornaday directed both Teen Beach Movie (2013) and Teen Beach 2 (2015) for Disney Channel, as well as being on hand as the movies’ choreographer.

Hornaday was nominated at the Directors Guild of America Awards for Outstanding Directing – Children’s Program for Geek Charming. He lost out to Amy Schatz who directed HBO’s A Child’s Garden of Poetry. The directors of both Lemonade Mouth and Sharpay’s Fabulous Adventure, two 2011 Disney Channel movies, were also nominated in this category.

RECEPTION

Geek Charming premiered on Disney Channel in the US on 11th November 2011.

The DCOM’s premiere was preceded by something called “Geek Chic Week”, which was a Disney Channel event, going from Monday 7th November up to Geek Charming’s premiere on 11th November. The event focused on showing movies and episodes of series celebrating “geeks”, such as episodes of Phineas and Ferb (2007-15), and movies like Lemonade Mouth (2011) and Princess Protection Program (2009). Behind-the-scenes clips of Geek Charming were also shown during this week[3]. I’m not sure how much I agree that their choice of programming was really focused on “geeks”.

On its premiere, Geek Charming apparently achieved viewership of 4.9 million viewers. In 2011, Disney Channel released six DCOMs, with Geek Charming being their second-to-last one of the year. Its viewing figures matched that of Sharpay’s Fabulous Adventure, the High School Musical spin-off movie, however, 4.9 million was actually the lowest viewership for Disney Channel movies that year, although not by much, and this was an average figure for Disney Channel at the time, before their numbers would drop off in the late 2010s. Disney Channel’s highest figure of 2011 for a movie was 7.6 million, achieved by Phineas and Ferb the Movie: Across the 2nd Dimension.

In terms of reviews, as is pretty typical for Disney Channel movies, Geek Charming received some highly positive reviews and some more negative ones.

On the positive side, Geek Charming was seen to be a fun, cute movie, perfect for its target age range of kids and tweens. These comments also stated that it had some heartfelt moments, some laughs, and a positive message of being yourself and not caring about being popular. Its two leads were generally considered to have done a good job with the material they were given. Having a star of Modern Family and a star of Pretty Little Liars also helped to bring in the target audience.

However, Geek Charming did not avoid the general negativity that these television movies tend to receive, about being cheesy and cringey. Alongside this though, the story was criticised for being unoriginal, shallow, and clichéd, which I would have to agree with. I feel like the whole “wanting to be Prom Queen” dream has been done to death in teen movies, and even with the attempt to make this dream seem less shallow, by having Dylan want to become Blossom Queen because her mother was, it didn’t work for me. 

LEGACY

Although at the end of Geek Charming, Josh says that him and Dylan should think about doing a sequel, there was never a sequel to Geek Charming. Dylan didn’t want to do one anyway, stating that sequels are never as good as the original, which isn’t always true, but I see her point. Not many non-musical Disney Channel movies get sequels, so really, it was not a surprise that the Geek Charming story ended here.

Something that is a bit surprising is that neither of the two leads, Sarah Hyland or Matt Prokop, became big Disney Channel stars, not going on to appear in multiple DCOMs or in series after Geek Charming premiered. This doesn’t always happen with the leads of DCOMs but for the most part, it would. Hyland did, however, become a major name thanks to her role in the ABC sitcom Modern Family, with ABC being a Disney-owned channel.

Prokop, on the other hand, has not acted since 2014, and there is a reason for this. Hyland and Prokop were in a relationship when they were making Geek Charming, reportedly being together from 2009. In September 2014, it came to light that Hyland had gone to court to secure a restraining order against boyfriend Prokop for abusive behaviour. Prokop had apparently attended rehab prior to the restraining order being granted[4].

I’m not about to go into details about what was alleged to have happened as that is a private matter and not relevant to this movie review; this isn’t a gossip column after all. The only reason I have chosen to mention this is because I read so many comments online when looking for an overview of opinions on Geek Charming that mentioned this incident. These comments were from people who said they used to love the movie, but now they know about the alleged abuse, they cannot like Geek Charming anymore, signalling that the two will forever be linked.

FINAL THOUGHTS

Much like any other Disney Channel Original Movie, Geek Charming has its die-hard fans; others who thought it was just alright; and those who hate it. I will say that on the whole though, I did read more positive than negative comments about the film itself.

Disney Channel movies are looked back on with a feeling of nostalgia. They help us remember simpler, happier times in our lives, since these memories and feelings can be tightly linked with whatever we watched at the time.

Sadly, we also have to remember that the people we see in these movies are actually real people who perhaps did not enjoy the DCOM or series they were in, or who did at the time but now cannot look back on it fondly, for whatever reason.

It just goes to show that Disney Channel, although wanting to help you navigate life, cannot shield you, its viewers, or even its young stars, from the troubles of this world forever.


REFERENCES

[1] Credit: Goodreads, ‘Geek Charming’, Goodreads.com, date unknown.

[2] Credit: Author Unknown, ‘Amy Loubalu’, GeekCharming.Fandom.com, date unknown.

[3] Credit: Pinch Raccoon and Milady Lover, ‘Disney Channel Geek Chic Week Promo (November 2011) (4:3)’, Pinch Raccoon and Milady Lover 2002 YouTube Channel, 15th March 2025.

[4] Credit: Esther Kang, ‘Julie Bowen Recalls Supporting Modern Family daughter Sarah Hyland During Previous Allegedly Abusive Relationship’, People.com, 4th June 2024.

Minutemen (2008)

  1. BACKGROUND
  2. PLOT
  3. CHARACTERS & CAST
  4. MUSIC
  5. PRODUCTION
  6. RECEPTION
  7. LEGACY
  8. FINAL THOUGHTS
  9. REFERENCES

BACKGROUND

Disney Channel Original Movies cover all manner of themes and topics.

Some of their most popular, and most relatable, are those that focus on life as a teenager or troubles at high school. Everyone has been through difficult experiences at that age, so making a DCOM based on that is an easy way of engaging an audience. These types of movies were the ones I watched more of on Disney Channel.

However, Disney Channel has also been known to stray into other areas, such as delving into the genres of fantasy and science-fiction, although many of these are still grounded in school and teenage life, such as Twitches (2005); Halloweentown (1998); How to Build a Better Boy (2014) – and the 2008 DCOM Minutemen.

You can probably be forgiven for not having heard of or watched Minutemen whilst it was on Disney Channel. I will admit that I was not the first one to it, because the most exciting new DCOM to come to the channel in 2008 for me was Camp Rock. After the success of High School Musical (2006), Disney Channel had upped their game in all areas of their programming, but none more so than in their musical DCOMs. I also enjoyed watching the third instalment of the Cheetah Girls franchise, The Cheetah Girls: One World, that year. Disney Channel is known for its musical movies, with these tending to be the highest rated. Minutemen was the only other DCOM released in 2008, but it passed me by. I remember it being advertised, but it just didn’t appeal to me like the musicals did.

I don’t actually know when I found Minutemen, but it was at least a couple of years later. I was more interested in watching it after its premiere because it meant that I was more familiar with some of its leading actors by the time I found it, just randomly one day. Jason Dolley and Chelsea Staub, now known as Chelsea Kane, were frequently seen on Disney Channel in the 2000s and early 2010s, so it helped me like it, despite not being too interested in the concept of time travel, a major part of the storyline of Minutemen.

I believe I had only seen Minutemen once in full before this week, so that obviously means that it didn’t become an instant favourite for me. I took me a while to appreciate any type of science fiction film, even Back to the Future (1985), which is referenced numerous times in Minutemen, so I’m not surprised my teenage self wasn’t bothered by it. But re-watching this week, I was impressed with the storyline and the level of acting by the young stars. I did enjoy it, but not as much as other DCOMs.

PLOT

Minutemen begins on the first day of high school at Summerton High School for three friends, Virgil, Derek, and Stephanie. Stephanie worries that high school might change them, as she is going to try out to be a cheerleader, and Derek is planning on joining the school’s football team. During try-outs for football and cheerleading, with Virgil watching nearby, a kid on a jet-propelled kart comes onto the field. This is Charlie, a kid genius who has skipped grades because of his intellect. Because of Charlie ruining football try-outs, the football players circle Charlie and start to bully him. Virgil tries to diffuse the situation, but it makes everything worse: they end up dressed as cheerleaders and tied to the school’s ram statue.

Three years later, everything has changed for the trio of friends. Derek is now a jock, and his girlfriend is Stephanie, who did become a cheerleader. Virgil has remained friends with Charlie – the joint bullying experience must’ve bonded them – though he is resentful that, in his Senior Year, he still hangs out with “nerds”. Although Virgil and Stephanie continue to talk on occasion, things between Virgil and Derek are different.

During class, Charlie bursts into Virgil’s class and tells him there is an “AV Club emergency”. Virgil follows Charlie to the computer lab, where Charlie shows Virgil a simulation of practical time travel. Virgil doesn’t believe it’ll work, but Charlie manages to convince him to go along with the crazy scheme of becoming time travellers. Charlie says they need another person to help them. Virgil approaches new kid, Zeke, who comes across as the bad-boy-loner type. The three meet to discuss the project and Zeke agrees to it.

The group begin to build their time machine, having managed to convince Vice Principal Tolkan to let them set up a new club and base it in Room 77 after giving him change for the vending machine. Room 77 was Charlie’s pick for their “club” as it is a huge basement, originally set to be the school’s fallout shelter. Over time, they clean up the basement, and start to get – or steal, I can’t really tell – parts for their machine. Once it is fully built, all three of them are too scared to try it out, so Virgil and Zeke pick up Charlie’s cat, Albert Felinestein, put goggles on it, and throw it into the machine’s vortex. Charlie is furious, but the cat comes out alive, just a bit frosty. They look at the watch they strapped to the cat and it is one minute behind, proving that the cat went back in time.

The next day, all three of them are brave enough to go into the time travel vortex themselves, wrapping up warm to avoid frostbite. Charlie warns them that they only have ten minutes to go back in time and come back, or else they may explode. Nice. The trio arrive in the past and realise it is yesterday. They quickly go to a shop to buy a lottery ticket with the correct numbers so they can win the jackpot the next day, however, they are refused the sale as they are not old enough to purchase the ticket. The three go to the “living statue” outside and ask him to buy the ticket, giving him the list of numbers and telling him to keep the ticket to give to them the next day as they need to get back to the present. On their return, they rush over to the shop to find the man did buy the lottery ticket – but kept the winning ticket for himself! Can we trust no-one these days?!

Virgil, Charlie, and Zeke then discuss a different purpose for their time travel machine, as Charlie didn’t like the idea of buying a lottery ticket anyway because it is cheating. Good for you, Charlie; you stick to your morals. They then see Chester, one of Charlie and Virgil’s less-than-popular friends. Football players have stolen Chester’s clothes, leaving him to run through the school halls naked. This gives the boys an idea. They’ll use their time travel ability to help embarrassed high school kids!

Just as the three are about to go back in time, Charlie realises that they really ought to have someone stay back to monitor the machine and make sure there are no problems. The boys argue about who will have to stay and miss all the fun, when a girl called Jeanette comes into the room, wanting to be a part of the “Back to the Future Fan Club”, the cover name for the time travelling. This gives Zeke and Virgil an idea; Jeanette can be the one to stay back. Charlie isn’t so sure he wants anyone else to be let in on the secret, but he eventually agrees – and Jeanette has a crush on Charlie so she’s happy to be a part of their gang, regardless of what it means. Though she does want to do something about their time travel outfits. Luckily, her dad owns a ski shop so she equips them with white ski suits and goggles to give them an air of mystery and legitimacy to their time travelling. They name themselves “The Minutemen”.

The three go back in time and help Chester by giving him clothes to wear. As their outfits conceal their faces and identities, the mystery group soon become popular at school as they continue to help other kids. Vice Principal Tolkan, however, is not impressed by these “Snowsuit Guys”, who he keeps seeing running about the school without permission. Tolkan vows to find and punish them.

Meanwhile, employees at Pacific Tech have been monitoring high readings and power surges that seem to be coming specifically from Summerton High School. It turns out the FBI is also investigating, covertly following Zeke, Charlie, and Virgil. This leads Charlie to admit to having hacked NASA, stealing some files they had from the 1960s related to time travel. Zeke and Virgil are furious with Charlie for getting them mixed up in something illegal, but Charlie assures them that if they just lay low for a while and don’t time travel, everything should be fine. Virgil isn’t too bothered by this anyway, because he’s annoyed at not getting proper credit for the good work they’re doing. Plus, the students all call them the “Snowsuit Guys”, even though that isn’t their name. AND the kids they have helped have all become kind of obnoxious…However, Virgil soon finds an important reason for them to time travel again. He is told by Stephanie that she has got accepted to her preferred college, but on a cheerleading scholarship. The next day, Virgil comes into school to discover that Stephanie has broken her leg after falling from a cheerleading pyramid. A broken leg will most definitely cost Stephanie her scholarship, so Virgil convinces Zeke and Charlie to go back in time to help her. The three agree to do that, and Virgil manages to catch Stephanie as she falls, saving her leg, but also giving himself away in the process.

Stephanie confronts Virgil the next day, saying she knows he is one of the “Snowsuit Guys”. As Virgil believes they have been rumbled, he admits to Stephanie that him, Zeke, and Charlie are time travellers. Stephanie is in awe of this; she was just going to say they must be psychic! Charlie continues to feel uneasy about their use of the time machine, feeling that it is having repercussions in the real world. But Virgil continues to find reasons to use it. Stephanie comes to Virgil with Derek, asking for his help as Derek was distracted during a football game, and cost the team the win. Derek begs Virgil for his help, saying that he’s sorry for everything that happened between them, reiterating that he tried to get the football players to stop during that incident on their first day of high school. Virgil wants to be popular so he agrees to help Derek. Derek is grateful to Virgil and starts inviting him to parties, but this leads to Virgil ignoring Zeke and Charlie. Soon after, Virgil gets a call from Stephanie in tears, saying she saw Derek cheating on her with mean girl Jocelyn. Virgil goes to comfort her. Derek then calls Stephanie, wanting to talk but she won’t take him back. Derek begs Virgil to go back in time to stop that event from happening.

As Virgil wonders what to do – help Derek get Stephanie back, or let things run their course and hope that him and Stephanie can finally be together – he is thrown in a van and taken to a warehouse. There, the FBI confront the boys, telling them they know that the boys stole information from NASA and have been using it to time travel. The boys refuse to admit anything and are free to go. The FBI will continue to monitor their activities. The three go their separate ways, their friendship and hopes of time travel destroyed.

But Virgil goes on alone, telling Derek he will take him back in time to stop Stephanie seeing him with Jocelyn on the day of the school dance. Virgil goes to the dance with Stephanie, but he is pulled away by Derek, wanting to go back in time now. The students all follow them, believing there will be a fight. In the meantime, Charlie has discovered that their time travelling led to the creation of a black hole on the school field. He confesses to the FBI, telling them they have about four hours to save the world. The FBI and Charlie storm the school to get Zeke, Virgil, and Charlie together to stop the black hole from consuming everything. There is only an hour left at this point so the guys suit up and walk to the black hole, ready to jump in, students clapping and cheering them, as their identities are revealed.

The ”Minutemen” jump into the black hole, and fall into the local park. Using a remote machine that Charlie whipped up, they begin to reverse the polarity. Charlie believes they have about twenty minutes until they can return. They then go to the school to try and stop past Charlie accessing the component he used to make his time travel machine, something to do with that kart, because they’ve found they are back at their first day of high school. At the same time, Virgil wants to change what happened that day, so he never became “a nerd”. Charlie is hurt by this, telling Virgil that day was also the day that Charlie finally found a real friend. Charlie and Zeke walk away, leaving Virgil to do whatever he plans to do. Virgil watches over the scene below, and discovers that Derek never tried to stop the bullying, like he claimed, but was actually a part of it.

Charlie and Zeke discover that the portal is collapsing and don’t have enough time to get back through it. Suddenly, Virgil rides up in Charlie’s old kart, having changed nothing about the bullying incident. He drives the three of them to the portal – but accidentally goes the wrong way. They’ll never make it in time! Oh, but wait. Zeke has that grappling hook he takes with him on every time travel escapade. He uses the hook and sends the kart in the right direction. The kart destroys the town on the way but they get through the portal in time.

They land, in their ski suits, back at school, on what was the day they first time travelled. As they walk through the school, they see that nobody knows anything about them or the “Snowsuit Guys”. Their mission was a success. Virgil goes to the library where he spoke to Stephanie that day, and tells Derek that he knows what he did that first day of high school and that he knows Derek is cheating on Stephanie with Jocelyn. Virgil then tells Stephanie he likes her; she says she feels the same. Charlie also kisses Jeanette, just before Zeke and Virgil can remind him that Jeanette hasn’t kissed him yet, as she had done before they went into the black hole…She doesn’t mind though. Charlie then starts to talk to Virgil and Zeke about a new idea around teleportation. The two quickly carry him away, not wanting to get mixed up in any more of Charlie’s “experiments”.

CHARACTERS & CAST

Virgil Fox initially seems hopeful about his first day of high school. He’s got his two best friends with him, what more does he need? But one event can change everything, and from that point, although Virgil has made new friends, he has become frustrated that he has become associated with “nerds”. Although Virgil talks and listens to Charlie, for most of the movie it seems like he merely tolerates him. Virgil seems to blame Charlie specifically for his problems. I hate to break it to him, but if Stephanie and Derek were going to be a cheerleader and a jock respectively, then the chances are their friendship wouldn’t have lasted anyway. Popularity does strange things to people. And in that scenario, Virgil would’ve been all alone, even without Charlie to call his friend. When Charlie comes up with the idea of time travel, suddenly, Virgil thinks this is quite cool – but once again, Virgil uses it as an opportunity to become popular and more liked amongst other students. It doesn’t really work that way until Stephanie learns about it and she tells Derek. But when Virgil gets the chance to go back and change his first day of high school so he never met Charlie and became unpopular, he doesn’t do it. I never thought Virgil was going to go and do that, because, although I’ve made him sound like a bad guy, he’s not.

Virgil does have some unresolved issues, there’s no doubt about that, and he forgets who his real friends are at times, yet he’s still a likeable character. This is all down to the actor, because Virgil could’ve ended up as a terrible main character if the wrong person was cast. Jason Dolley was cast as Virgil. Dolley had a long career with Disney Channel, beginning with the DCOM Read It and Weep (2006), where he played Connor. Dolley went on to star as Newt in the series Cory in the House (2007-08), and then as Pete in the DCOM Hatching Pete (2009). Dolley later was cast as PJ Duncan in Good Luck Charlie (2010-14) and its DCOM, Good Luck Charlie, It’s Christmas! (2011). After this, he appeared as Kevin in the ABC series American Housewife (2016-21). Most recently, Dolley wrote and starred in the short film The Unicorn That Never Lies (2024).

Charlie Tuttle hasn’t had an easy time at high school, because he is so much younger – and smarter – than everyone else. He’s an easy target for bullying and thanks to Virgil coming to his rescue on that first day, Charlie finds he does have a friend, someone he can talk to and who might stick up for him. Charlie is a genius; however, his high-achieving personality leads to him getting himself into trouble. Just because the possibility of time travel is waiting to be discovered doesn’t mean you should hack into NASA and steal their old research on the subject. Charlie is ecstatic to have figured out how to time travel, but he soon discovers that his, Virgil, and Zeke’s actions have caused damage to the world, culminating in a black hole. Charlie admits that he made a mistake and finds a way to resolve it. He just wanted to advance the world of science; he never meant to destroy it!

Charlie Tuttle was played by Luke Benward, who had already starred in the film How to Eat Fried Worms (2006) as Billy Forrester prior to his role in Minutemen. Benward went on to appear as Alan Wheddon in Dear John (2010); and came back to Disney Channel to star in the DCOMs Girl vs. Monster (2012) as Ryan, and Cloud 9 (2014) as Will Cloud. Benward also appeared as Beau, Teddy’s boyfriend, in the final season of Good Luck Charlie (2010-14). After Disney, he went on to be cast as Dillon Sanders in the Pretty Little Liars spin-off series Ravenswood (2013-14) and as Bo Larson in the Netflix movie Dumplin’ (2018).

Zeke Thompson is a new student at Summerton High School, first seen as he arrives to school on a motorbike. He seems like the silent, loner type, but Charlie and Virgil notice that he has engineering skills which may be useful to their time travel project. Although it might seem that Zeke doesn’t have time to hang out with science geeks, he is intrigued by this plan and agrees to help them; Zeke thinks the idea of time travel is cool. Much of the plot resolves around Virgil and Charlie’s friendship, and the dynamic between Virgil, Stephanie, and Derek, so Zeke doesn’t get all that focus, however, he helps find students who might need their time travel experience to avoid embarrassment and he is loyal to the cause, sticking firmly with Charlie on points, such as not betraying each other to the FBI, and not continuing to time travel when things start to look tricky.

Nicholas Braun also had a bit of history with Disney. Prior to his casting as Zeke, he was cast as Zach in the Disney movie Sky High (2005). After Minutemen, he went on to appear as Ed in the DCOM Princess Protection Program (2009), and then as Lloyd in Disney’s Prom (2011), which was not a DCOM, though it does feel like one. Since his “Disney days”, Braun has become an incredibly successful actor, appearing as Michael in Date and Switch (2014), alongside Dakota Johnson and Sarah Hyland, and as Josh in How to Be Single (2016), which also featured Dakota Johnson, and Rebel Wilson. He is perhaps most known for his role as Greg Hirsch in the critically-acclaimed series Succession (2018-23). Recently, Braun portrayed both Jim Henson and Andy Kaufman in the movie Saturday Night (2024) and is set to star in the movie Famous alongside fellow Disney alumni Zac Efron and Debby Ryan.

Moving on, Stephanie Jameson was one of Virgil’s closest friends before high school. At high school, though, things are a little bit different. Stephanie is a cheerleader, but she does make time to speak to Virgil. She’s not like one of those awful cheerleaders you see in movies who drop all their friends when they finally become popular. Stephanie isn’t actually all that happy about being popular. She thinks Virgil and his friends look much happier than any of the popular kids ever do. Virgil is smitten with Stephanie, and for once, I was actually rooting for the “nerd” to win the heart of the popular girl, because she was just so nice!  

Chelsea Staub, now known as Chelsea Kane, was cast as Stephanie. Like the three actors I’ve just talked about, Kane also had a history with Disney Channel. After Minutemen, she went on to star as Stella Malone, alongside the Jonas Brothers, in the Disney series Jonas (2009-10), before being cast as Alexis Bender in StarStruck (2010), alongside Sterling Knight. Also for Disney, Kane voiced the character of Bea Goldfishberg in Fish Hooks (2010-14). Outside of Disney, Kane placed third in Season 12 of Dancing with the Stars and played the part of Riley in the ABC series Baby Daddy (2012-17). She returned to voice acting again in 2019 to voice the character of Loy for the series Archibald’s Next Big Thing (2019-21).

Then there is Virgil’s ex-best friend Derek Beaugard. For most of Minutemen, Derek is also Stephanie’s boyfriend, but he turns out to be a cheater – big surprise there – so Stephanie dumps him. Derek then asks Virgil to take him back in time to avoid the moment that Stephanie saw him with another girl. Derek convinces Virgil to do this because he claims that during that bullying incident on their first day of high school he tried to get the other football players to stop doing what they were doing. Well, it’s a good thing that big, black hole stopped Virgil from helping Derek because it turns out Derek is a liar as well as cheat, actually contributing to the football players’ bullying of Charlie and Virgil, and not stopping it, as Virgil sees when they go back in time to save the world. Derek is just awful.

Steven R. McQueen was cast as Derek. He went on to be cast as Jeremy Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries (2009-17), and then as Jimmy Borrelli in Seasons 4 and 5 of Chicago Fire (2012-present). Oh, and that girl Derek was caught with was, Jocelyn, was played by Kellie Cockrell, who might look familiar to Halloweentown fans, as she played Sapphire Sinister in Return to Halloweentown (2006).

Then there are a couple of Virgil and Charlie’s friends to mention. One is Chester, who is frequently bullied by the jocks, but once Virgil, Charlie, and Zeke go back in time to help him one day, Chester becomes a real jerk, ignoring Virgil and Charlie, who only risked their lives to stop him being humiliated, and even starts to bully the jocks. All returns to normal, though, once the Minutemen go back and sort out that black hole. Then, there is Jeanette. Jeanette is a bit weird and hyper, coming on a little bit too strong for the socially awkward Charlie when she’s trying to show she has feelings for him. Eventually, Charlie learns to love Jeanette’s quirks and they become an oddly cute couple.

Chester was played by Dexter Darden. Darden went on to be cast as Frypan in The Maze Runner trilogy (2014-18) and appeared as DeVante in the reboot series of Saved by the Bell (2020-21). Most recently, he portrayed Muhammad Ali in the Peacock miniseries Fight Night: The Million Dollar Heist (2024), which starred Kevin Hart. Jeanette was played by Kara Crane, who went on to guest star in episodes of series like The Suite Life on Deck (2008-11); The Mindy Project (2012-17); and Baby Daddy (2012-17).

Finally, there is Vice Principal Tolkan. Tolkan isn’t bothered by the bullying epidemic he clearly has going on at his school, not even batting an eyelid when he sees a student trapped in a vending machine. Instead, he’s bothered about getting the right coins to get the snack he wants. Tolkan is happy to let “the normal order” take precedent over basic human rights, but that does mean that when Chester becomes a bully to the jocks, Tolkan suddenly wants to discipline because that goes against the status quo. What is it with DCOMs and corrupt teachers. We have Tolkan here; we had Brenigan in Lemonade Mouth (2011); where does it end? Vice Principal Tolkan was played J.P. Manoux, who should be familiar to Disney Channel fans for playing Vice Principal Hackett in the Disney Channel series Phil of the Future (2004-06). He also replaced David Spade from The Emperor’s New Groove (2000) as the voice Kuzco in The Emperor’s New School (2006-08), and voiced the character of Mr. Fraley in the Disney Channel animated series The Replacements (2006-09).

MUSIC

Minutemen isn’t a movie packed with songs, but one in particular was familiar to me.

This song was “Like Whoa”, performed by Aly & AJ, which played during Virgil, Zeke, and Charlie’s building of their time machine. It was written by Aly and AJ Michalka – who themselves starred in the DCOM Cow Belles (2006) – Antonina Armato, and Tim James. “Like Whoa” was part of Aly & AJ’s second album Insomniatic, released in 2007.

Another song I instantly recognised as being performed by Corbin Bleu, although I had not heard the song before, was “Run It Back Again”, which can be heard during the montage of the Minutemen helping students and being investigated by the FBI. “Run It Back Again” was written by Matthew Gerrard and Robbie Nevil. The music video features clips from Minutemen. It is also a track on Radio Disney Jams, Vol. 10, released in January 2008.

At the party that Virgil attends with Derek and Stephanie, I believe the song “Thinking About It…Baby” is playing, which was written and performed by Salme Dahlstrom. At the school dance, there is also a song that sounds a bit like “Johnny B. Goode” being played by the school band. When Stephanie and Virgil dance later, there is a different song playing. These seem to just be riffs on 1950s songs, since that is the theme of the school dance, and it’s a small reference to Back to the Future, and its setting of 1955. There is no information on these songs and they are not credited.

One final song to mention that is also not credited is the music that is playing during the End Credits. This is a mini-blooper scene that turns into a dance party with all the cast and crew. All I know is that the song goes “put your hands up, put your hands up, put your ha-ha-ha-ha-hands up”. I tried to search for it, tried Shazam, but it doesn’t exist apparently.

Nathan Wang is credited as the composer for Minutemen. Wang has composed the music for other DCOMs including Hatching Pete (2009); Wendy Wu: Homecoming Warrior (2006); and Christmas…Again? (2021), amongst many other non-Disney projects.

PRODUCTION

Science fiction is a common genre in entertainment, both on-screen and off.

On-screen, some of the most popular science fiction franchises have involved space travel, such as Star Wars and Star Trek. Although space travel is advancing, we are not yet living in a world that looks anything like those in science fiction films. However, others in this genre have become less science fiction and more “science fact”.

Some science fiction movies that have been focused on getting the science right include Christopher Nolan’s Interstellar (2014), whose plot has a basis in theoretical physics, and Ridley Scott’s The Martian (2015), which follows an astronaut’s attempts to survive on Mars[1]. A movie that comes somewhere in between science fiction and “science fact” is Back to the Future, one of the most popular science fiction franchises ever, in itself an inspiration to other science fiction films. Minutemen takes some ideas from this movie in its own exploration into time travel.

For fans of Back to the Future, there are many subtle references within Minutemen, aside from the time travelling storyline. One is that Charlie has named his pet, in this case a cat, after Einstein, and Doc Brown did the same with his dog in Back to the Future. Jeanette can also be seen at one point looking at the school newspaper, which changes its headlines as soon as the Minutemen have changed the past; this is something that happens in Back to the Future. You might also notice that Virgil’s last name, “Fox”, the same as that of Marty McFly actor Michael J. Fox, and that Vice Principal Tolkan is named after actor James Tolkan, who played Principal Strickland in the movie. A big mention of the movie comes in the fact that the boys named their club, the “Back to the Future Fan Club”. Obviously, they knew that they were re-enacting the movie in real-life.

I could go into detail about the never-ending problems with the scientific inaccuracies and plot holes that exist within Minutemen and Back to the Future that others have somehow had time to find. I’m not going to do that, because I don’t really care about accuracy in movies like this, because there is too much still to be discovered in the world of science. I will instead mention just one.

Time travel is not currently physically possible, however, theoretically, it has been discussed with many possible outcomes. For example, one theory that neither Back to the Future nor Minutemen manage to follow is the “grandfather paradox”. The example used to explain it says that if a time traveller went back in time and killed his grandfather before he could have children, then this would mean the time traveller never existed, so couldn’t actually go back in time to do that. In Minutemen, the boys go back in time to fix issues and return to the present to find that it’s like they never happened. This goes against the grandfather paradox. This theory led to the belief that travelling backwards in time was not possible, and has caused many viewers of movies like this to comment on inaccuracy.

But there have since been discussions, including theories from Stephen Hawking, that debate whether it is possible to travel back in time, at least to an earlier point in time that you’ve already been to. This would mean that Minutemen could work, however, this relies on the fact that things would be unalterable in that past timeline – which Minutemen does not stick to. Alternatively, there is a lot of discussion about quantum physics and parallel timelines, which are too complicated for me to understand[2]. All I know is that parallel timelines are explored in Back to the Future, specifically Back to the Future Part II.

My point here is that Minutemen took a lot of influence from Back to the Future, and in doing so, it took some of Back to the Future’s scientific inaccuracies and made them their own. However, that does not mean that Minutemen doesn’t have a good story, because it does, and it was good for Disney Channel to create a science fiction-based movie. Science fiction isn’t a particularly common genre for Disney, with their Zenon trilogy ending in 2004. Minutemen was their first science fiction movie since then, but Zenon takes place in space in the future, not in present day with some elements of science within it, like Minutemen. There wouldn’t be another science fiction-themed DCOM until The Suite Life Movie in 2011.

Minutemen was directed by Lev L. Spiro. After Minutemen, Spiro went on to direct the DCOM Wizards of Waverly Place: The Movie (2009) and some episodes of the Disney Channel series Jonas (2009-10). More recently, he has directed some episodes of UnReal (2015-18) and Insatiable (2018-19). The screenplay for Minutemen was written by John Killoran, with David Diamond and David Weissman being credited for the story.

The actors enjoyed working with Spiro during filming on Minutemen, and Spiro in turn enjoyed working with them. It seemed like a fun, creative atmosphere on set. One area where this was clear was in the stunts. Minutemen is not a high action thriller, however, there were still moments of stunt work, and the actors got to do quite a lot of it. Jason Dolley, Luke Benward, and Nicholas Braun ended up doing lots of jumps and dives to film the shots of them going into and coming out of the time travel vortex. They also did some work on wires for their characters spinning through the vortex. Although the vortex doesn’t look particularly realistic, it is worth remembering this is a TV movie from 2008. Benward was also able to drive the “runaway” kart in Charlie’s first scene in the movie.

There is also another actor that should be mentioned here and that is Tennessee the cat, who played Albert Felinestein. Although the cat is not seen all that much in Minutemen, Albert Felinestein was part of a key moment in the movie: the first test of the time travel machine. The cat actually had to be sprayed with something to make it look like it had been frosted up during the time travelling. But don’t worry; the cat was not thrown into the air when the boys throw it into the vortex in the film. A toy cat was used as a “stunt double”.

The coldness aspect of time travelling, which saw the DeLorean freeze during the time travel sequences of Back to the Future, did mean that the boys had to wear big, thick snowsuits. This may’ve been easy to do had this shoot been entirely inside, or shot during winter, but it was not; it was filmed in summer. Dolley, Benward, and Braun had to do a lot of activity in those costumes and did struggle at times in the hot weather[3]!

Minutemen was filmed in August 2007 in Utah, with two schools being used as filming locations: Murray High School, based in Salt Lake Valley; and Highland High School in Salt Lake City. It seems that Murray High School was used as the exterior of Summerton High School, with a giant bronze ram statue being placed outside the school entrance, with “Summerton High School” and “Rams” wording being added to the building. It supposedly confused some registering students; however, the props were removed before school started. Highland High seems to have been the setting for Summerton’s playing field[4].

Utah has been a fairly common filming location for Disney Channel, with others being filmed in Utah including Cloud 9 (2014) and Good Luck Charlie, It’s Christmas! (2011). Murray High School is not even a stranger to Disney Channel, as it was used as the filming location for Read It and Weep (2006) and the High School Musical trilogy (2006-08)[5].

RECEPTION

Minutemen premiered on Disney Channel on 25th January 2008 in the US.

It reportedly reached around 6.5 million viewers on its premiere. This is about average for a Disney Channel Original Movie release for the time, potentially slightly above average. The DCOMs with the best viewing figures tended to be the musicals, or the ones with the biggest Disney Channel stars. Although Minutemen features a lot of Disney stars as we now know them, at the time, none of the main actors had been in many Disney projects before, so Disney Channel didn’t have that to market the movie fully. Although I’m from the UK and not the US, I don’t remember Minutemen being heavily advertised on the channel, however, the other two releases of 2008, Camp Rock, and The Cheetah Girls: One World, were. It is worth noting though that in the US, Minutemen actually had slightly more viewers than the third Cheetah Girls movie, which had viewership of around 6.2. million. I also think Minutemen fared quite well for a January movie release. DCOMs released over the summer or towards Halloween I always felt were the most exciting ones.

Looking at audience reviews, I was surprised to find so many positive ones for Minutemen. That’s not to say I think it deserves more negative reviews, because it doesn’t, but just that many reviews of DCOMs tend to be overly critical. In Minutemen’s case, many felt that the storyline was fun and smart, with better-than-expected acting. I would definitely agree with this statement. Many liked the references to Back to the Future that are peppered throughout Minutemen. It was also appreciated that this is a DCOM that is centred on three teenage boys, and outcasts at that. Many other DCOMs do not do this, although Disney Channel were clearly trying to appeal to this demographic during the 2000s, as you can see with movies like Jump In! (2007) and Hatching Pete (2009).

However, Minutemen did not escape any negative reviews, as no film ever can. Some said that Minutemen was “forgettable”. To be fair, in amongst all the other DCOMs that have been released, I would say that Minutemen has been forgotten by many Disney Channel fans, unless they happened to have watched it enough times at a younger age to make it a favourite. But the reason it may have been forgotten isn’t because the movie is low-quality; it’s because the DCOM world has been saturated with musicals. Others were quick to point out the inaccuracy of the time travelling within Minutemen, and there were some comments about how the black hole and “end of the world” scenario was a little bit overdone, especially with the four-hour time limit to fix everything. Four hours is a random amount of time for something as cataclysmic as a black hole consuming the world – or was it just the US? – but I didn’t think it was excessively dramatic.

Personally, I think Minutemen is a better-than-average DCOM, with a different type of story and pretty good acting. It’s certainly not anywhere close to being one of the worst DCOMs I’ve seen. 

LEGACY

Unlike Back to the Future, which spanned two sequels, merchandise, a TV series, and a fandom that are extraordinarily loyal, Minutemen didn’t get that.

Minutemen instead may even get confused with The Minutemen characters from the DC comic book series Watchmen. Minutemen are also the name of characters in other comic books, including those from Marvel. Minutemen, or Minuteman, has also been used as the name of different organisations or groups in the US over the years, including in the American Revolutionary War. This term generally refers to rapid deployment of people.

One good thing to come out of Minutemen was the careers of its stars, with the four main actors having multiple Disney credits. Jason Dolley mentioned during a 2020 video he appeared in on Christy Carlson Romano’s YouTube Channel – the voice of Kim Possible for anyone unfamiliar, as well as Ren Stevens in The Even Stevens (2000-03) – that he was one of the few actors to have been in the most DCOMs with four, joint with Brenda Song. Song has in fact been in five. Although some were quick to point out the inaccuracy in his statement, many actors who have been in more than four DCOMs were in series, such as Raven-Symoné in The Cheetah Girls and Zenon films, and Ashley Tisdale, in the High School Musical and Phineas and Ferb movies. Dolley was in four completely unrelated, standalone DCOMs, as well as two Disney Channel series, which is still impressive. If nothing else, Minutemen was a stepping stone to success for its Disney Channel stars.

Minutemen also went some way in breaking Disney Channel’s reliance on musicals after its High School Musical hype, and finding a way of appealing to boys, instead of only on pre-teen and teenage girls.

FINAL THOUGHTS

Minutemen is not my favourite DCOM, and I didn’t even see it until after its release. I’ve always liked musicals, so I was always excited for those, and I’d also choose to watch DCOMs with actors I already knew. Minutemen wouldn’t be able to meet that second requirement for a few years, but when it did, I went ahead and saw it.

It wasn’t a particularly memorable movie experience to be honest, but re-watching this week, I was impressed with it. The storyline covered the scientific background of time travel, as well as the potential homeland security issues that may come with this sort of endeavour, making Minutemen more complex a movie than others that are generally about high school. Minutemen managed to combine the time travel with this aspect.

Minutemen is a movie for the outcasts, once again proving that it’s the ones who no-one imagines anything of who do the things that no-one can imagine.

Alan Turing reportedly said that; I can’t take credit for it.


REFERENCES

[1] Credit: BBC Bitesize, ‘Five times the movies got their science right’, BBC.co.uk/bitesize, October 2022.

[2] Credit: Andrew May, ‘What is the grandfather paradox?’, LiveScience.com, 31st January 2022.

[3] Credit: Disney Channel, ‘Minutemen 2008 DVD Overview’, Diamond Boy’s Disney DVD Overviews YouTube Channel, 12th January 2024.

[4] Credit: Jennifer Toomer-Cook, ‘Disney moment for Murray, Highland’, Deseret.com, 3rd September 2007.

[5] Credit: Jennifer Guzman, ‘Got Disney+? Keep an eye out for these movies filmed in Utah’, KSL.com, 12th November 2019.

Prom Pact (2023)

  1. BACKGROUND
  2. PLOT
  3. CHARACTERS & CAST
  4. MUSIC
  5. PRODUCTION
  6. RECEPTION
  7. LEGACY
  8. FINAL THOUGHTS
  9. REFERENCES

BACKGROUND

The 80s are having a bit of a moment right now. Whether that’s in movies, music, fashion, whatever, the 80s are back and people are loving it, both young and old-er.

I don’t know what caused this resurgence initially. Perhaps it was the series Stranger Things (2016-present). That’s set in the 80s, isn’t it? I wouldn’t know, I’ve never seen it. Much too scary for me. Or maybe it’s just the right time. Every decade seems to become fashionable again at one time or another.

I’ve had my own “journey through the 80s”. It started with music and my dad’s CDs, then I moved over to movies, starting with comedies like ¡Three Amigos! (1986) and Planes, Trains and Automobiles (1987), before going over to some of the teen movies like The Breakfast Club (1985) and Pretty in Pink (1986). I’ll just ignore the fashion; it’s not for me.

Once there’s a new trend afoot, everyone wants a piece of the pie – and that includes Disney. Prom Pact is their tribute to the iconic movies of the 1980s.

Prom Pact was released to Disney+ just a day later than its Disney Channel premiere. It is labelled a Disney Original Movie, and not a Disney Channel Original Movie. Now that many international Disney Channels have since shut down, the humble DCOM title has become something a little bit different as the majority of us have to rely on Disney+ for all our Disney Channel content, making the DCOM name redundant and inaccurate.

Surprisingly, I did watch Prom Pact very soon after its Disney+ release, which is odd for me as most of the time new films just sit on my watchlist and are normally removed a few months later, unwatched. A big draw for me watching Prom Pact was the two lead actors: Milo Manheim and Peyton Elizabeth Lee; both Disney alumni that I know and like. But that wasn’t all. I was also taken in by its 80s references, hoping to see nods to some of the best 80s movies as well as hear some great music. I wasn’t disappointed. I also find the whole American concept of prom fascinating, so over-the-top and everyone’s way too over-excited about it. I’m probably jealous. My prom here in Britain was terrible. My school didn’t even organise it, so everyone ended up at a village hall and just got drunk. Such a waste of time.

Prom Pact happens to be a very funny movie too, and a more adult one from Disney, moving into rom-com territory at times, alongside the usual teenage coming-of-age material. It was so grown-up that two different versions of the film actually exist: one for Disney+, and one for its original Disney Channel premiere, which edits out some dialogue. 

PLOT

Prom Pact begins like so many teen-centric movies: in a high school gym, at a pep rally. Except our main character is not at the pep rally. No, Mandy is sat outside, refreshing her college application status, hoping that Harvard, her top choice school, has accepted her. She is disheartened to find it has not changed and instead turns her attentions to helping those less fortunate, by attempting to take the contents of the Lost and Found bin to donate to the homeless. The school guidance counsellor, Ms. Chen, tells Mandy to stop what she’s doing and orders her to go to the pep rally. Begrudgingly, Mandy does as she’s told.

Inside, she attempts to vent to her best friend, Ben, about how all these basketball jocks are dumb and will never succeed in later life, but Ben actually wants to focus on the pep rally as they are about to announce the theme for their senior prom. Mandy isn’t at all bothered by this, but shuts up so Ben can listen. The theme is announced to be – drum roll, please – the 80s! Almost immediately after this, the student body hears the Ghostbusters theme start up. Oh yes, it’s time for the first promposal of the year. Mandy doesn’t find this at all sweet or cute and basically rolls her eyes at it. I am with you there, Mandy! I don’t like that sort of thing in marriage proposals, let alone promposals. Since when did all special life moments have to be so elaborate and public, full of props and prying eyes? Ugh.  

Ben is struggling to accept that he and Mandy have spent so much of their time in high school missing out on big events and opportunities to mix with others who aren’t just each other, with the two of them spending every Friday at the bookstore, then the movies, then the waffle house. Sounds pretty good to me – apart from the waffles, I’m not much of a dessert person – so I don’t know what Ben is complaining about. Nor does Mandy but she can see how much missing out on parties is bothering Ben so she does something corny that she never expected to do. She writes “PROM?” in ketchup on the restaurant placemat and asks Ben to go to prom with her, as friends. There are some rules though: no limos, no slow dances, none of that naff stuff. Ben accepts the conditions of this “prom pact”.

The next day at school, disaster strikes. Mandy finds she has been waitlisted by Harvard. Distraught, she goes to Ms. Chen and declares that her life is over. Ms. Chen tells Mandy it’s time to think about back-up schools. This is answered with a flat “no”. So, the only other route is to get a really good letter of recommendation from someone. Mandy suddenly has an idea: the basketball captain’s father is a senator, and he also went to Harvard. If she can get a recommendation from him, then Harvard will have to accept her. The only problem is, she’s never actually talked to Graham Lansing before…

With their two friends, Zenobia and Charles, who are much more socially mobile than Ben and Mandy, they discuss how Mandy can get close to Graham. Mandy is told that Graham should be at a party tonight and is currently failing his psychology class, so a plan is enacted. Mandy and Ben go to this high school party to find Graham so Mandy can offer to tutor him, since she did that class last year. The two split up to find Graham, with Ben stumbling upon a conversation with cheerleaders. He happens to have a crush on one of them, LaToya Reynolds, and Ben being the socially awkward person he is tries to include himself in the conversation, only to get nervous and start cleaning up all the empty cups around them. Mandy doesn’t have any luck either, and only finds Graham standing behind her after she basically calls him a grunting neanderthal. They make a quick exit.

Luckily, Ben did overhear that Graham is meant to be going to a community garden project tomorrow so Mandy knows she’ll have to go too. At the community garden, Graham goes over to help Mandy use a nail gun, and she apologises for what she said to him. She then offers to tutor him in his class. Graham is uncertain why a girl he’s never spoken to would want to help him, but he agrees to tutoring sessions.

At their first session, Graham is five minutes late and is too distracted by more promposals going on around him to pay attention. Mandy’s normal teacher approach won’t work on Graham so she uses a language she knows he’ll understand: basketball. This works so well that Graham decides it’s time for him to teach Mandy how to play basketball, with a simple four-letter word: BEEF. Balance, Eyes, Elbows, Follow-Through. It actually works. Graham then takes Mandy to a youth team that he coaches and Mandy learns that she’s the only girl he’s ever brought there, making Mandy feel just a little bit special.

The next Friday night, Mandy tells Ben that she’ll be tutoring Graham at his house so she won’t be able to do their usual Friday night routine, but she’s determined to get there for the movie. However, at Graham’s house, Mandy is invited to stay for dinner and believing that Graham’s father will be there, she stays put, ditching Ben. Ben is about to return her movie ticket when he sees LaToya Reynolds in the queue ahead of him. Ben has recently learned that LaToya does know of his existence and awkwardly invites her to take the spare ticket and watch the movie with him. She happily accepts.

At dinner, Graham’s father is busy with work so isn’t there, but Mandy tells Graham’s mother all about her dreams of attending Harvard. Graham’s mother then invites Mandy to come to a fundraiser event next weekend, so that she can actually talk to Graham’s father about Harvard and get some tips.

But next Saturday starts to roll around and Mandy remembers that Saturday night is supposed to be the night she goes to dinner with Ben for his birthday. Ben is annoyed that Mandy is ditching him yet again, so to soften the blow, Mandy tells Ben he should ask LaToya to go with him. He isn’t sure about that, but he does ask, and she agrees to go out with him. Mandy also tries to make it up to Ben by giving him gifts and balloons whilst at his Saturday job at the grocery store. Everything is still good between them. For now.

At the fundraiser, Graham and Mandy slow dance together and they kiss. Mandy realises that she’s fallen for Graham, so when she gets the chance to talk to Graham’s father and learns that he is disappointed in Graham for being “dumb”, she tells him that Graham is a very special person and that actually she doesn’t need anything in return for her tutoring. But as she’s about to find Graham, she overhears his brothers talking about a girl who was over at their house earlier that day. Graham’s brothers think he’s only brought Mandy here to impress their dad. Mandy is humiliated and runs out of the room. She didn’t bring her phone though so uses the venue’s phone to call Ben, the only number she knows – you don’t know your home landline, Mandy? – and interrupts his date. As she sounds so upset, Ben rushes out of the restaurant, leaving LaToya with the bill and the humiliation of having her date run out on her. What Ben should’ve done here is ask to pay the bill now, and then offered to walk LaToya to her car or take her home first. Come on, Ben – use your brain, dude!

Ben picks Mandy up from the fundraiser and she apologises for ignoring him and missing his birthday. Ben’s ok with it and they still have prom anyway. The next day at school though, things aren’t ok between Mandy and Graham, or Ben and LaToya. Ben says sorry to LaToya and says he shouldn’t have just left her. She forgives him for that and then asks him to go to prom with her. Torn between friendship and the girl he likes, Ben has to refuse LaToya’s invitation and say he’s already going with Mandy. Unsurprisingly, that doesn’t go down too well. Mandy, meanwhile, is asked to prom by Graham, who says that the girl his brothers were talking about was just helping him plan his promposal to her. Mandy seemingly forgets all about her “prom pact” and says she’ll go to prom with Graham. Mandy excitedly tells Ben, but again, unsurprisingly, that news doesn’t go down well with him. Ben angrily calls Mandy out in the school car park, saying she was only using Graham to get that recommendation letter. This bust-up happens to have been recorded by some other student, so naturally, Graham sees the whole argument, and breaks up with Mandy – before handing her the letter of recommendation his dad wrote for her. Ouch.

Mandy doesn’t know what to do with this letter, as it’s exactly what she wanted but now she just feels guilty. She returns the letter back to Graham and knows she has to make things right with everyone. Luckily, it’s prom day. Mandy drives to see Ben first and does a poorly choreographed dance on his driveway, which makes Ben feel uncomfortable enough to accept her apology just to get her to stop! Mandy tells Ben to get dressed because they have some stops to make before prom: the bookstore, the movies, and the waffle house. They eventually make it to prom – and discover that no-one else is dressed in 80s-style prom outfits, making them feel awkward once again. They try to ignore that and enjoy the dancing regardless.

Soon, it’s time for Prom King and Queen to be announced. LaToya is announced as Prom Queen, and Prom King goes to – Ben?! The Prom King and Queen have to dance together but obviously with everything that went down between them, it’s a little awkward. Ben publicly apologises to LaToya once more and they finally kiss.

Mandy catches up with Ms. Chen at prom and thanks her for rigging the vote for Ben to win Prom King. She tells her to never speak of it again. LaToya and Ben then order Mandy to check her Harvard application. Mandy reluctantly does so and is surprised to find she’s been accepted! It turns out Ms. Chen wrote her a letter of recommendation; it might not have been from a fancy Senator but it still worked out.

At graduation, Mandy gives her Valedictorian speech – oh sorry, I mean, Salutatorian speech; Mandy only got a 94 in P.E. so I guess that’s not good enough for Valedictorian? I don’t know; I’m not American. That’s besides the point anyway. Mandy publicly says how much Graham helped her that year and then proceeds to give everyone the same piece of advice he gave her: BEEF. Make sure your life is balanced, you keep your eyes open, keep your elbows safe, and follow through with your actions and promises.

At the end of graduation, Mandy says goodbye to Ben as she will be spending the summer at Harvard, but that’s ok because him and LaToya are now an official couple. Graham also comes to talk to Mandy, telling her he’ll be attending a college chosen for him by his dad. The two leave on good terms.

Some time later, Mandy is in a bar on campus and surprisingly sees Graham there. He tells her he decided to take a year out to do some non-profit work in the city instead of going to college. Mandy is overjoyed to see him and they reconcile with a kiss.

CHARACTERS & CAST

Mandy Yang doesn’t care about high school and spends her senior year only thinking about getting into Harvard, the only college she’ll even think about going to. Mandy doesn’t care about prom, or sports games, or parties. Her focus is on Harvard and only Harvard. Although there’s obviously a determination to achieve a dream here, which is admirable, Mandy’s life is completely out of balance, forgetting that life doesn’t only start when you get to college and that she’s actually missing out on some big life moments during high school in her pursuit of Harvard. It’s not until she discovers that Graham, part of a group Mandy likes to call “The Everests” because their life has supposedly already peaked, is actually a good guy and much more ambitious and kind than she expected does Mandy let her guard down a bit and start to enjoy life. But she only fully accepts that she needs more in life than college after she’s lost all of her friends and has to spend her day at prom making amends with everyone. And then karma strikes in the best way and she gets accepted to Harvard anyway! Mandy’s a tough cookie, and she represents the pressure that so many high schoolers put on themselves to get accepted to “the best” colleges. It’s not worth the stress and there are so many other options. When you’re 17, 18, it’s never the end of the world; it just feels like it.

Peyton Elizabeth Lee was cast as Mandy. Lee said that, since she had been acting since the age of 10, she understood Mandy’s drive to succeed and her ambitious nature, but Lee tries to find a good balance in her life between her career and having fun, so she’s different from Mandy in that way. Lee is well-known for her portrayal of the titular character in the Disney Channel series Andi Mack (2017-19). She also voiced the recurring character of Rani in The Lion Guard (2016-19) and then starred in the Disney Channel-aligned movie Secret Society of Second-Born Royals (2020). Lee also starred as Lahela Kameāloha in the Disney+ series Doogie Kameāloha, M.D. (2021-23).

Ben Plunkett is a bit socially awkward and resentful of the fact he hasn’t been brave enough to experience all that high school has to offer. Ben has felt comfortable and happy in his friendship with Mandy but as the end of senior year approaches, he realises that Mandy will be going off to Harvard and he’ll be left in this town with the fellow high schoolers who either ignore him or vaguely pick on him – he was given the unfortunate nickname of “No Nuts” Plunkett after an allergic reaction on a school trip…Kids can be so cruel. Ben wants to experience the last few moments of high school with everyone else, by going to parties, going to prom, and maybe, just maybe, finally talking to his crush, the popular cheerleader LaToya Reynolds. Luckily, Mandy going off and tutoring Graham gives Ben just the push he needed to get out there and live his own life.

I can totally see Peyton Elizabeth Lee being similar to Mandy – ambitious, driven, strong, and opinionated, just perhaps a bit less judgemental! On the opposite side, Milo Manheim, who played Ben, does not strike me as the awkward and shy type. In fact, Manheim stated that he had first auditioned for Graham, which would have matched Manheim’s previous “leading man” roles, but was cast as the best friend[1]. This didn’t hold him back though, I don’t think, and Ben turned out to be a sweet guy and a loyal friend, as well as the funniest character in the film. I laughed out loud multiple times during Ben’s embarrassing interactions with LaToya. Milo Manheim is best known to Disney fans for playing Zed in the Disney Channel musical franchise ZOMBIES. He also competed in Dancing with the Stars (2005-present) in 2018 and came in second place. Recently, Manheim secured the role of Wally on the Paramount+ series School Spirits (2023-present) and was cast alongside Peyton Elizabeth Lee as Nico in Season 2 of Doogie Kameāloha, M.D. (2021-23), which arrived on Disney+ on the same day as Prom Pact.

Graham Lansing is the “dumb jock” who happens to not be so dumb after all. Mandy judges Graham based on his popularity and his basketball skills, but when she gets to know him properly as she tutors him in psychology, Mandy learns that there’s much more to him. He likes to do basketball coaching for one thing, and he actually struggles to fit in with his academically-focused family. Graham’s father is a senator, and he judges his sons on their academic abilities and nothing else, so for Graham to be the popular, sporty one in the family, that stands for nothing. Graham’s father doesn’t think his son is smart and thinks Mandy is doing a huge favour by taking time out of her day to tutor Graham, as it must be a tough job. This shows how difficult Graham’s home life must be, especially when we learn that Graham’s father has selected an “appropriate” college for Graham to go to, so as not to embarrass the family.

Graham was played by Australian actor Blake Draper in his first major film role, after having smaller roles in series like Clickbait (2021) and the Aussie soap Neighbours (1985-present) in 2018. Draper was recently announced as the star of the upcoming biopic A. Rimbaud about the French poet Arthur Rimbaud.

So that is the three main characters of Prom Pact, but there are definitely some more to mention. One is the school guidance counsellor Ms. Chen, who is less empathetic than you might expect a guidance counsellor to be, being quite direct and blunt with some of her advice! Ms Chen is also quite happy to rig the vote for Prom King just because Mandy asked her to do it to help fix Ben’s relationship with LaToya. Margaret Cho was cast as Ms. Chen. Cho started out her career in stand-up comedy before moving into acting roles. Some of these include All-American Girl (1994-95) as Margaret Kim; Drop Dead Diva (2009-14) as Teri Lee; 30 Rock (2006-13) as Kim Jong II, for which Cho was nominated for the Primetime Emmy for Outstanding Guest Actress in a Comedy Series; Good on Paper (2021) as Margot; and as Charlie Utada in Season 2 of The Flight Attendant (2020-22).

For the students, LaToya Reynolds, the cheerleader who isn’t snobby and stuck-up like so many are on screen, was played by Monique A. Green. One of Green’s earliest roles was in An American Girl: Summer Camp, Friends for Life (2017) as Jordan. She went on to be cast as Olive Cooper in Season 1 of the Disney+ series Big Shot (2021-22) prior to her casting in Prom Pact. Green also appeared in a few episodes of Black-ish (2014-22) as Niecy. Mandy and Ben’s two other friends at school, Zenobia and Charles, were played by Arica Himmel and Jason Sakaki. Himmel is most known for her role as Rainbow “Bow” Johnson in the Black-ish spin-off Mixed-ish (2019-21).

Finally, I’ll briefly mention Mandy’s supportive but outspoken parents, Tom and Alyssa. David S. Jung was chosen for the part of Tom Yang. He had previously been cast as the recurring character Rip Tide in Doogie Kameāloha, M.D., alongside Peyton Elizabeth Lee. Wendi McLendon-Covey was cast as Alyssa. She is well-known for her roles as Rita in Bridesmaids (2011) and Beverly Goldberg in The Goldbergs (2013-23). I also know her from the sitcom Rules of Engagement (2007-13) where she played Liz, and McLendon-Covey also voices the character of Nancy Green in the Disney Channel series Big City Greens (2018-present) and its subsequent movie.

MUSIC

The soundtrack for Prom Pact consists of a lot of songs, some are modern hits, others are 80s songs and 80s movie themes.

Some of these 80s movie themes were easy to place as they were mostly used for the various promposals that took place throughout Prom Pact. These include the Ghostbusters theme by Ray Parker Jr.; “Old Time Rock and Roll” by Bob Seger from Risky Business (1983); and “(I’ve Had) The Time of My Life” by Bill Medley and Jennifer Warnes from Dirty Dancing (1987).

At the prom, we also hear numerous well-known 80s songs, since it is an 80s-themed prom after all. A cover of “Love is a Battlefield” from Peyton Elizabeth Lee and Milo Manheim; “Let’s Dance” by David Bowie; “Mony Mony” by Billy Idol; “Only You” by Yazoo; and “I Wanna Dance with Somebody” by Whitney Houston are clearly heard during these scenes. Just before prom, to make amends, Mandy also does a promposal-redo for Ben, whilst dancing awkwardly on his driveway, to the song “Safety Dance” by Men Without Hats.

Another 80s song that is heard briefly is “Addicted to Love” by Robert Palmer. I think a student is singing it as part of a promposal whilst Mandy and Ben are at the waffle house. The final piece of 80s music to make its way into Prom Pact is “The Promise” by When in Rome, used in the final scene of Graham and Mandy reuniting at a bar near Harvard.

Of the more modern tunes, Ben and Mandy can be seen and heard rocking out to “Believer” by Imagine Dragons in Ben’s car. Milo Manheim has confirmed that he was not driving in this scene, but that the car was being towed[2]. That’s good because it’s quite clear that neither of these two are focusing on the road during this scene! Another contemporary music hit played during Prom Pact is “Bad Guy” by Billie Eilish which is used during a montage of Mandy’s tutoring sessions with Graham. Just after, when Graham takes Mandy to see the basketball team he coaches, “Shooting Star” by Michelle Lewis, Randall Cooke, and Mia Bojanic can be heard.

At the party that Mandy and Ben attend to try and talk to Graham so Mandy can offer to tutor him, a few modern songs are heard: “Art of the Strike” by Numbs; “Coincidance” by Handsome Dancer; and “Like Dat” performed by Marquise Butcher. The song “Reinvent Urself” by Robbie Nevil features as Mandy and Ben mess about looking for prom outfits. This song is also used in the End Credits of Prom Pact.

You’ll also hear “What Makes You Beautiful” by One Direction during Graham’s promposal to Mandy, along with the song from Risky Business, as Mandy was a childhood fan of One Direction, though she doesn’t like to admit it. The song “Fall on Me”, performed by Great Big World and Christina Aguilera is used as the slow dance song at Graham’s father’s fundraiser where Mandy and Graham have their first kiss. As Mandy is getting dressed for the fundraiser, “Feeling Butterflies”, by Meaghan Smith is playing. Mandy’s life soon starts to fall apart after the fundraiser, and the song heard as Ben drives her home is “Don’t Cry”, originally performed by Seal, but performed by Alice Lee here. As Mandy realises that Graham and Ben are both annoyed at her and she debates what to do about Harvard, Nazareth’s “Love Hurts” also performed by Alice Lee can be heard.

Then there is the song “Bulldogs United” by The Newton Brothers, which I can only assume is an original song, written to be the school song and used in their pep rally. Only four songs are credited in Prom Pact with “Bulldogs United” being one of those. The other three are the two Alice Lee songs mentioned above and Peyton Elizabeth Lee and Milo Manheim’s cover of Pat Benatar’s “Love is a Battlefield”.

There were apparently plans to have many more songs included in Prom Pact, however, there was not enough movie to fit them all in so compromises had to be made[3]. I have probably missed some because there were so many, or ones that I simply couldn’t place – like two pieces of jazz music playing at the fundraiser, for example – but this is the majority of the Prom Pact soundtrack. I am quite disappointed that “St. Elmo’s Fire (Man in Motion)” by John Parr from St. Elmo’s Fire (1985) didn’t make it though. I love that song.

PRODUCTION

The idea for Prom Pact came from a story written by Anthony Lombardo with input from Julie Bowen and Rachael Field, who were executive producers on this film.

Julie Bowen is well-known for starring as Claire Dunphy in the ABC sitcom Modern Family (2009-20), winning the Primetime Emmy for Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series in both 2011 and 2012 for this role. Bowen was also Adam Sandler’s “leading lady” in the Halloween comedy film Hubie Halloween (2020) and is set to appear in Happy Gilmore 2 (2025). Bowen had met both writer Lombardo and producer Field whilst working on Modern Family.

They all worked on the premise for Prom Pact together, wanting to make a modern twist on the 80s teen movies. Bowen stated that she had grown up watching John Hughes movies so wanted this to be a tribute to those, whilst also acknowledging the more outdated themes within them and find a way of correcting them in this new movie. Some of these are discussed in one scene where Ben, Mandy, Zenobia, and Charles are talking about the problems with certain 80s movies during lunch. For example, The Breakfast Club (1985) might be about being yourself, but suggests that you have to look a certain way to get a guy to like you, and Weird Science (1985) is about two guys creating the perfect woman on their computer who is basically a pin-up model, showing that 80s movies were very sexist at times. Mandy also mentions how disappointed she is that her parents treasure a picture of her dressed up as Tom Cruise’s character Joel in Risky Business (1983) when she was little, despite that movie being about a teenager running a brothel from his parents’ house, which isn’t exactly inspirational – or shouldn’t be anyway.

Lombardo pitched the idea of a feminist senior being more obsessed with Harvard than prom and parties, so this character would be pushing back against the common 80s movies tropes. It was also important to the group that they showed the importance of purely platonic friendships between girls and boys, instead of just focusing on romance, as many 80s teen movies do.

Prom Pact was first announced by Disney Branded Television in February 2022. Melvin Mar was named as one of the producers, having previously worked on Doogie Kameāloha, M.D. and Fresh Off the Boat (2015-20). Anya Adams was announced as the director, having also worked on Fresh Off the Boat. A brief description of the plot was given, and Peyton Elizabeth Lee and Milo Manheim were listed as the two leads[4]

Bowen stated that she had never been to a prom before, as she went to a small boarding school in Rhode Island which did not have a prom. She was obsessed with the idea of prom being this huge rite of passage because she had never experienced it[5]. But she was certainly not the only one on set who had never been to a “normal” high school prom. Peyton Elizabeth Lee, having worked on Disney projects for so much of her childhood, didn’t get the chance to go a normal prom either. During the premiere of Prom Pact, some of the cast did discuss the “Disney Prom”, which appears to be an annual event held for all those child and teen actors who work for the company. Lee said she went to three or four of these proms but never went to a real one. Milo Manheim said he first met Lee at one of these Disney Proms with the prom that year being named The Emerald Ball[6].

Prom Pact was filmed in Vancouver and there were a variety of different measures taken on set to make this production more sustainable, which would’ve matched Mandy’s environmentalist nature. These included reducing emissions and minimising waste to make a greener production. Electric vehicles were provided for crew and refillable water stations were available for use. Electric generators were used at times instead of just diesel-powered ones too. In catering, plant-based options were available and compostable food ware was provided. Signage across the set detailed small actions that anyone could take to reduce their environmental impact[7].

RECEPTION

After Prom Pact’s initial details and some cast and crew members were announced in February 2022, Peyton Elizabeth Lee and Milo Manheim then attended the 2022 D23 Expo in September of that year to give fans a closer look at the new movie.

The Hollywood premiere was held on 24th March 2023, complete with a pink carpet – not red – to match the Prom Pact movie poster and the 80s movie Pretty in Pink (1986), I presume, before the first five minutes of Prom Pact were revealed on Disney Channel’s YouTube channel early on 30th March.

This led to the official premiere of Prom Pact on Disney Channel on 30th March 2023. 182,000 viewers are said to have tuned in for the actual premiere, which pales in comparison to some of Disney Channel’s other movies, but Prom Pact was still the highest-viewed kids’ television broadcast on that day. It’s likely that more and more people are moving away from cable TV and exclusively using streaming services now so that is potentially why the viewing figures may seem lower than usual.

Because of this, it made good business sense for Disney to release Prom Pact on to Disney+ just a day later on 31st March 2023, to give the movie a much larger audience. However, this did require two different versions of the movie. For anyone who has watched Prom Pact on Disney+, you’ll have noticed that there are some comments made around sex, as well as some scenes of underage drinking and small uses of swear words. This isn’t a big deal for teenagers or adults, obviously, but it’s not exactly child-friendly in places. This is why the Disney Channel version edited out some scenes and dialogue to fit their usual target audience. This “other version” may have come as a surprise to parents who might have only had access to the Disney+ version of Prom Pact but had still expected to see a typical DCOM. Apparently, Prom Pact became Disney Channel’s first TV-14 rated original movie with this Disney+ edit of the film. It is unclear how well Prom Pact did on Disney+ in terms of viewing figures, although some media outlets have stated that Prom Pact was the fifth most-watched film across all platforms in the US during its first week of release. Prom Pact later aired on Freeform on 4th May 2023.

Reviews for Prom Pact were generally positive, although the Disney+ version of the movie was a bit of a shock to some. I was surprised at some of the content, but it didn’t bother me. Prom Pact felt more like a Netflix teen coming-of-age movie, on the lines of To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before (2018) or The Kissing Booth (2018) rather than something like High School Musical (2006), which isn’t a bad thing but it did feel different.

Some of the more negative reviews focused on the fact that the character of Mandy was quite off-putting and unlikeable and that the movie itself felt a bit clichéd. Others also said it was odd to be aiming a movie at tweens and teenagers who have probably never seen any of the John Hughes movies it was trying to represent. I don’t think that necessarily matters because the nostalgia of the decade is not being aimed at them; it is being aimed at the adults or parents that may have chosen to watch it. The whole point of Prom Pact was to make a movie that is a tribute to 80s movies but felt contemporary and realistic.

Another big complaint was in a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it shot. Quite close to the beginning of Prom Pact, during the pep rally, rows of students on bleachers can be seen. The front row are real human extras, however, in the row behind, a line of expressionless CGI characters can be spotted clapping. I personally did not see this whilst watching the movie, although looking at it online, these characters do look quite disturbed and some quite rightly likened their appearance to Sims 2 characters. It’s quite funny but probably not for the filmmakers. Many were quick to point the finger at Disney for using AI, but it is actually just low-quality CGI being used here[8]. The AI debate strengthened online though due to the SAG-AFTRA strikes that were ongoing at the time, with just one area of discussion being around the use of AI in the entertainment industry and the lack of protections for actors and writers. This caused many to label Disney as hypocritical. But they weren’t because, again, this was CGI, not AI. Bad CGI characters will always be a thing as long as the technology exists. I’d be more afraid of these CGI babies coming to the new live-action Rugrats film[9]

On the positive side though, many felt Prom Pact was cute, entertaining, charming, and light-hearted fun. These viewers also liked this more mature movie from Disney. Looking at reviews of other teen-centric Disney Channel Original Movies, teenagers felt that those movies were too sanitised and did not reflect a true high-school experience. No doubt Prom Pact was at least a step closer to creating a more accurate account of school life in the US. The chemistry between the three lead characters also did not go unnoticed.

Prom Pact went on to be nominated for Outstanding Fiction Special at the 2nd Children’s and Family Emmy Awards. It lost to The Guardians of the Galaxy Holiday Special (2022), also from Disney. It’s a shame for Prom Pact but I don’t even like Marvel movies and I liked that Guardians Holiday Special a lot!  Prom Pact did, however, win the Best One-Off, Special or TV Movie in the Tweens/Teens Programming category at the Kidscreen Awards.

LEGACY

Since Prom Pact was a standalone story that ended with a definitive conclusion, it should not be a surprise that a sequel has never been released. 

But if viewers wanted more from Milo Manheim and Peyton Elizabeth Lee, they didn’t need to look far because they were both in Season 2 of Doogie Kameāloha, M.D., which will suit anyone who was hoping for those two to get together in Prom Pact.

Despite Prom Pact specifically being about platonic friendships and not romance between the two characters, because they arrived to prom looking like Duckie and Andie from Pretty in Pink (1986), some viewers might have been hoping for Mandy and Ben to suddenly end up together – though I accept that this was not the point and wouldn’t have made much sense given the events of Prom Pact.

But I did really want Duckie and Andie to get together in Pretty in Pink and I was so sad when they didn’t. And then I was even more sad when I found out that the original ending had the two together, but then test audiences booed and complained about it, wanting Andie to end up with Blane, so that’s what they got. Way to bow to peer pressure, John Hughes.

Anyway, what was I talking about?

FINAL THOUGHTS

Oh yeah, Prom Pact.

I liked Prom Pact even more the second time I watched it. It was funny, it was sweet, it had some very likeable characters, and everything was tied up nicely in a little bow by the end of the film. Mandy got the guy and the college, and Ben got his girl too.

I also enjoyed the references to 80s movies, which I had thankfully seen so I understood some of the Easter eggs and nods to these films. I don’t think I would’ve felt particularly out-of-the-loop if I hadn’t anyway.

The 80s as a trend are still not going away with many more television and film reboots in the works to keep the masses satisfied. I’m not a fan of reboots so Prom Pact was good because it was a love letter to the 80s without feeling like a rip-off of some other film.

This trend will likely dissipate soon enough, making way for some other decade, but as long as we have high school and prom, the quintessential teen movie will still be around.  


REFERENCES

[1] Credit: Alex Reif, ‘The Making of Disney’s “Prom Pact”’, LaughingPlace.com, 30th March 2023.

[2] Credit: Shine on Media, ‘PROM PACT Cast Share Favorite Memories & Dance Moves at Premiere I Interview’, Shine on Media YouTube Channel, 26th March 2023.

[3] Credit: Rania Aniftos, ‘‘Prom Pact’ Soundtrack Jam-Packed with 80s Hits From David Bowie, Whitney Houston & More: Exclusive’, Billboard.com, 28th March 2023.

[4] Credit: Nellia Andreeva, ‘Peyton Elizabeth Lee & Milo Manheim To Headline Disney+ Movie ‘Prom Pact’ From Julie Bowen & Melvin Mar’, Deadline.com, 6th February 2022.

[5] Credit: Dana Rose Falcone, ‘Julie Bowen Says Disney’s ‘Prom Pact’ Is ‘Not a Movie About Dresses and Limos’ – See the First Trailer’, People.com, 24th February 2023.

[6] Credit: Shelby Stivale, ‘Exclusive: Is Disney Channel Prom Real? Milo Manheim and Peyton Elizabeth Lee Spill the Tea on ‘Great’ Memories’, J-14.com, 28th March 2023.

[7] Credit: Disney, ‘Sustainability on Set: Behind the Scenes with Disney Original Movie “Prom Pact”’, Disney.com, date unknown.

[8] Credit: Inga Parkel, ‘Disney Plus viewers notice ‘horrible CGI’ in new movie Prom Pact: ‘They look like Sims 2 characters’, Independent.co.uk, 5th April 2023.

[9] Credit: Rebecca Rubin, ‘‘Rugrats’ Live-Action Movie in the Works at Paramount With CGI Babies’, Variety.com, 2nd October 2024.

Adventures in Babysitting (2016)

  1. BACKGROUND
  2. PLOT
  3. CHARACTERS & CAST
  4. MUSIC
  5. PRODUCTION
  6. RECEPTION
  7. LEGACY
  8. FINAL THOUGHTS
  9. REFERENCES

BACKGROUND

In 2016, just under two decades after the first official Disney Channel Original movie, Under Wraps, premiered in 1997, Disney Channel released their 100th DCOM. What a milestone.

This 100th DCOM was Adventures in Babysitting, which just so happened to be a remake of an 1980s movie of the same name, released by Disney in 1987 under the Touchstone Films label. When Disney release a movie under Touchstone Films, historically that has meant the movie contains more mature themes and content than the average Disney movie. This was the case with the PG-13 rated Adventures in Babysitting (1987).

After years of speculation around a sequel, and then a remake, of the 1987 movie, Disney delivered with their own Disney Channel movie of the same name, which featured a few stars of Disney Channel at the time, including singer Sabrina Carpenter.

I’d only vaguely paid attention to Adventures in Babysitting previously, when I randomly caught it on the Disney Channel. I didn’t think much of it; I don’t believe I even got to the end of it. I have never seen the 1987 Adventures in Babysitting, so I didn’t have that previous interest to get me motivated to watch it properly. But now I’ve decided to go back and review every DCOM, I had to go back and see it.

Sadly, I still wasn’t that impressed after re-watching it. Don’t get me wrong, there isn’t anything bad about Adventures in Babysitting, and the two lead actresses of Sabrina Carpenter and Sofia Carson, of Descendants fame, were very likeable and easy to watch. But the overall plot of two babysitters getting into various scrapes in the big city with the five children in their care didn’t feel particularly original or unique to me. Honestly, it bored me after a while because it all felt very samey. Bad guys were chasing them, then there was some misunderstanding that led to a moment of humour, then they were chased again, another misunderstanding, and so on. I just couldn’t stay interested, and after an hour, I really just wanted the movie to end.

Perhaps that is from my lack of understanding of the original, or it might be because I’ve never been a babysitter – I’m not a huge fan of kids, actually – and big cities scare me, especially at night. These elements are kind of key to the story of Adventures in Babysitting, so it was never going to be a film for me, unfortunately.

PLOT

Adventures in Babysitting begins with two girls heading to an interview for a photography internship. Jenny is quite high-strung and uptight, with everything in her life neatly organised and painstakingly planned out; she has her whole future lined up. We also have Lola, who is around two years older than Jenny and is a bit messy and wild. Lola doesn’t have her whole life planned out but she loves photography and desperately wants this internship.

At the interview, the girls are told to go away and find some inspiration for photographs over the weekend, with the actual interview now being moved to Monday. At the same time, the girls accidentally swap phones when both are knocked to the floor, but neither are aware of this. Going back to her car, Lola finds she’s being given a parking ticket for $80. “Lola’s” phone then rings and she answers; it is Zac, Jenny’s crush, inviting her to a concert. Lola realises this is not her phone but turns Zac down anyway, without explaining that she isn’t Jenny. Why you wouldn’t just say “Jenny’s not here right now, but I’ll tell her to call you back”, I don’t know. But Lola is attempting to flirt with the officer writing her ticket, so she’s obviously got other things on her mind instead of common courtesy! Now she needs $80 but luckily, she answers another of Jenny’s calls. Her teacher needs a babysitter for the evening so Lola, pretending to be Jenny, says her reliable friend Lola can babysit tonight.

Meanwhile, Jenny has arrived at her own babysitting job at the Coopers, looking after their two daughters: the glamorous little Katy, and the rebellious teen, Emily. At this point, Jenny then notices that she has Lola’s phone and not her own. Seeing as young people are meant to be constantly attached to their phones, you’d think Jenny would’ve noticed this a little bit earlier… Anyway, Jenny then calls her actual phone, hoping to speak to Lola. The person who picks up is AJ Anderson, one of Jenny’s teacher’s kids, who says that Lola is currently dealing with a fire in the kitchen so can’t come to the phone right now. Jenny immediately drives the Coopers over to the Anderson’s house to figure out what is going on.

At the Anderson’s, Jenny learns that Lola was too busy trying to relax in the hot tub to worry about the three kids she was meant to be looking after, leaving Bobby to mess up the kitchen and cause this fire. Emily Cooper then discovers that Trey, the eldest Anderson kid who was meant to be grounded, has snuck out to go to a Psychic Rockets concert in the city. Jenny freaks out and says she’ll drive there and get him home. The kids blackmail Jenny into taking all of them to the city, saying that they’ll tell their mum that Jenny doesn’t even know Lola if she doesn’t, so all of them go. But Jenny’s car isn’t big enough so they take the Anderson car instead, with Jenny driving slowly so it doesn’t get a scratch, dent, or mark on it whatsoever.

In the city, Jenny parks up by a pawn shop where they believe Trey bought his concert tickets from. The owner of the dark, dingy shop points them to the back, where the ticket scalper is playing with a sword. Lola, with Jenny hiding behind her, asks if a kid bought tickets from him this evening. He finally says that one did and that the kid said something about going for pizza. Emily pipes up that Trey probably went to Mario’s, his favourite pizza place; she has a crush on him so naturally, she’d know these things. As Jenny readies everyone to get back in the car to go to Mario’s, a purple weasel is let loose in the shop, thanks to Bobby. As the pawn shop owner rushes to catch it, Lola takes a photo with her camera, as she looks for spontaneous moments for her art. As everyone tries to get back to the car, they see it being towed away. They are told to come to the tow yard with $100 by midnight if they want to get it back today. Where are they going to get $100 from?

The group then finds that the owner and scalper are chasing them, as apparently that ferret was stolen and they don’t want evidence that they have it. Lola and Jenny hurry the kids onto a city bus and because of their arguing in front of the driver, they get away with not paying the full fare. They eventually get to Mario’s where they find Trey and confiscate his concert ticket. To get the $100, Lola thinks they should resell Trey’s ticket; it’s the only plan they’ve got. Meanwhile, Jenny overhears some girls from her school saying that Zac has decided to take some other girl to the concert and is devastated, not knowing that Lola rejected him on her behalf. Emily has also gone and got herself a sneaky henna tattoo having asked Lola – not Jenny – for permission first. Jenny is horrified and starts to shout at Lola, but they are interrupted by those two guys chasing them again. The group find themselves cornered in some sort of warehouse that washes uniforms and boiler suits. To escape, Lola comes up with a plan of hiding themselves in the suits and being carried up and over the heads of those two guys. It works and they escape via the laundry shaft.

The group then head to the concert venue, with Lola going off to try and resell Trey’s ticket, however, it turns out that this is illegal and Lola is arrested. At the police station, Lola explains that her and her friends are being chased by two men, but the officer is reluctant to believe her. Luckily, the officer who gave Lola a parking ticket at the start of the movie, Officer James, seems to work here and talks to Lola. He tries to tell her how much trouble she’s in, but she pleads with him, saying she doesn’t want to go to jail. Lola is released, and who should be waiting for her but Jenny and the kids. Jenny has just discovered that Emily has dyed her hair green, who, in a fit of teenage rebellion, walks away and calls her mum, leaving a message about what’s been going on, and AJ has met her roller derby idol at the police station. Lola and Jenny continue to argue about Lola’s irresponsibility.

As the two are arguing, the two men come back and see AJ holding Lola’s camera; she is chased down the street by them, with Lola stealing their car to chase after her. AJ manages to outrun and outsmart both the guys, and when the group catches up, they run into a building which turns out to be a rap club. The DJ won’t let them leave without rapping something, so after a brief, but pretty awkward, rap battle between Lola and Jenny, they are free to go. But outside, they see the Cooper parents nearby. It turns out they were worried after hearing Emily’s message on their phone and have gone to the police station to try and find her. The police officers laugh at the suggestion they’ve got their kids locked up here, and the parents head back to the party, believing it was just a prank.

Emily has to admit that she called her parents, which annoys everyone but there’s nothing they can do about it. Katy reminds everyone that her mother keeps a $100 bill in her purse, so they can sneak into the party and get that to pay to get the car back. At the party, which is in a planetarium, Jenny and Lola manage to blag entry by saying this is a field trip – even though it’s late and there is a private party on at this venue… They get to the cloakroom and discover that the Cooper mother’s coat is not there. Meanwhile, Bobby gets distracted by the kitchen at this venue and starts making dessert. The Head Chef is only too pleased to have some random kid in his kitchen, licking and touching all of his ingredients without washing his hands first. Where are the health inspectors when you need them?

To get to the Cooper mother’s coat, Lola is dressed up like a British socialite and takes a seat at their table. She successfully grabs the $100 bill from the mother’s purse and leaves. The scalper and the pawn shop owner have also entered the party but the ferret gets free, causing a panic amongst the party guests. Security is called to detain them and the police arrive to arrest them, with the ferret being taken to an animal shelter.

Lola and Jenny learn that they actually make a good team, but Lola admits that Zac had invited Jenny to the concert that evening and implied Jenny wasn’t interested as she was distracted by Officer James. Jenny is furious, but Lola wants to make it right and gets them all over to the concert venue. To get in to the venue, Lola has to part ways with her special camera, which the security guard wants as payment. Inside, Jenny is given a quick makeover and told to talk to Zac. The concert has just ended but Jenny wades through the crowd to get inside. She runs onto the stage and shouts Zac’s name. She tells him that she would’ve said yes to his invitation to the concert and the two reconcile.

But more trouble is brewing. The Andersons have found that their house alarm is going off and nobody was answering the house phone so they are heading home. The group quickly rush to get the car back from the tow yard and Lola speeds back to the Anderson’s house. They beat the parents there but the house is an absolute mess: Trey is tasked with cleaning the car; Emily with cleaning the dog; whilst everyone else cleans up the kitchen and laundry room. Jenny then takes the Cooper kids home, so Lola can wait for the Andersons to arrive. They are none the wiser, so they get away with their little escapade. At the Coopers, Jenny is about to head home when Zac arrives and asks her out on a date. She gladly accepts. Heading home herself, Lola is pulled over by the police. It’s Officer James and he has her driving license which she left at the police station. He also asks her out; she accepts.

On Monday, Jenny arrives – late – for the internship interview to find Lola already there. She actually tells Lola that she’s turning down the chance to interview for the internship so Lola will get it as she wants and deserves it more. The movie ends with Lola sending her pictures from that night – having remembered to remove the memory card from her camera before parting ways with it – to Jenny, Emily, Katy, AJ, Bobby, and Trey. But she also accidentally sends them to the Anderson mother as well who is horrified to learn what went on that night – oops…

CHARACTERS & CAST

Jenny is the classic example of a “goody two-shoes”. She is the perfect babysitter, the perfect student, and has never done anything wrong in her life, apparently. But that doesn’t mean that Jenny thinks she’s amazing. In fact, she’s quite shy around guys and clearly feels a bit inadequate compared to others her age, but she’s always been organised and is being given the opportunity to attend college early. We don’t get to meet Jenny’s parents but I think it’s probably their influence which causes her to be uptight and stressed all the time! What’s important is that Jenny learns, from Lola, that being perfect all the time is tiring, not worth it, and not all that fun, so it’s nice to see her freeing herself from all that expectation by the end of the movie and getting to live life like a normal teenager for once.

Jenny was played by Sabrina Carpenter, whose breakthrough acting role came from starring as Maya Hart in Girl Meets World (2014-17), the Disney Channel spinoff of the series Boy Meets World (1993-2000). She went on to appear in a few movies such as Tall Girl (2019) and its 2022 sequel, as Harper, as well as Work It (2020) as Quinn, all for Netflix, but nowadays pretty much everyone in the world now knows Sabrina Carpenter as one of the next biggest singing sensations. She has been releasing music since 2014, however, shamefully, I’ve only heard Sabrina Carpenter’s music recently. Sorry, Sabrina… And that was just the one song, “Espresso”, which I love after having heard it about three times on the radio during one car journey earlier in the year! It’s a great song, reaching No. 1 in the UK, Australian, and US Pop Charts. Some of her other more recent songs include “Feather” and “Please Please Please”, with her new song “Taste” released in August 2024.

Lola is not at all like Jenny. For one thing, Lola is about two years older than Jenny and has no plans to go to college. She wants to get the photography internship because she is passionate about it and sees a future career, whereas Jenny wants it for her college application. Lola is clearly talented, but she’s also quite chaotic, both in her art and her life. Lola has managed to accumulate numerous parking tickets, only wants to babysit to get money to pay for those tickets, and doesn’t plan anything; she just barrels into situations and hopes for the best! But Lola is a caring person; she wants the kids to be able to express themselves and do what’s best for them and she also wants to help Jenny with the situation she got them into by choosing to go in the Anderson’s hot tub instead of looking after the children… Lola learns from her mistakes though, apologises for them, and it turns out that Jenny and Lola become good friends because of everything they went through.

Sofia Carson was cast in the role of Lola, having just starred as Evie, daughter of the Evil Queen, in Descendants (2015). After the Descendants trilogy, Carson received a main role in Pretty Little Liars: The Perfectionists (2019) and went on to appear in multiple Netflix films including Feel the Beat (2020) and Purple Hearts (2022), where she also wrote, and performed on, the soundtrack. Carson also performed at the Oscars in 2023 alongside Diane Warren, singing the song “Applause” from the movie Tell It Like a Woman (2022), which was up for Best Original Song that year.

Now to the kids. Let’s start with the Cooper girls. The oldest is Emily and she is a bit of a rebel, initially wanting to shave her hair off at the start of the movie before deciding just to dye it with green streaks. She later gets a henna tattoo as well and is generally not in a good mood because she has a crush on Trey Anderson who seems to be too obsessed with Jenny to notice Emily. The youngest Cooper is Katy and she is a bit of a princess. She likes to wear her mother’s make-up, clothes, and expensive jewellery, even taking her mother’s earrings all the way into the city – luckily, she doesn’t lose them or she’d be in big trouble because those earrings are one of a kind, you know! Katy uses her fashion expertise in two notable occasions during Adventures in Babysitting; the first to disguise Lola as a socialite to sneak into the parents’ party and the second is to make Jenny look more like a concert-goer – and less like a “stick-in-the-mud” – to impress her crush. I like the Cooper sisters, with the girls’ opposite natures balancing each other out.

Emily Cooper was played by Nikki Hahn. She had played Bianca Russo in the Wizards of Waverly Place television special Alex vs Alex in 2013. After Adventures in Babysitting, Hahn appeared in the recurring role of Gina Tuscadero in American Housewife (2016-21). Mallory James Mahoney was cast as Katy Cooper here, before going on to star as Destiny Baker in the Disney Channel series Bunk’d (2015-24) from Season 3 onwards.

 For the Anderson kids, let’s talk about the surly teenager, Trey. He is the reason why Jenny and Lola’s “easy” babysitting jobs become huge disasters. Because Trey is moody about being grounded, he decides to sneak out of the house and go to a concert with his friends, assuming that the babysitter won’t possibly notice that he isn’t there. And if Lola hadn’t been called by Jenny to get her phone back, then he might have just gotten away with it. But he didn’t so everything that happens to the group in the city is all Trey’s fault, really. It’s also his fault that Emily is starting to go off the rails since he won’t pay any attention to her. He finally does near the end, but if I was Emily, I’d be telling him “too little, too late, pal”.

Then, there are the other two Anderson children, Bobby and AJ. Bobby is the cooking fanatic, who is concerned with finding the perfect ingredient for his baking competition through the events of Adventures in Babysitting, with this ingredient turning out to be crushed seaweed. I might have blamed Trey for everything that happens in Adventures in Babysitting and that’s still mostly true, but then again, Bobby does cause the purple ferret to escape from its cage in the pawn shop and let the group in on the fact that this ferret is in fact stolen, so having these two men chasing them is Bobby’s fault. AJ is the youngest Anderson kid who loves roller skating, even getting to meet her roller derby heroine at the police station of all places. So, what I’ve learnt here is that boys are trouble and girls aren’t!

Max Gecowets was cast as Trey Anderson, going on to appear as Jonathan in the mini-series Dreaded Rose in 2017. Bobby was played by Jet Jurgensmeyer, who has voiced characters in children’s series such as Bubble Guppies (2011-23) and T.O.T.S. (2019-22). He later went on to appear as Boyd Baxter in Season 7 and 8 of sitcom Last Man Standing (2011-21). AJ Anderson was played by Madison Horcher.

Speaking of boys, Jenny and Lola have their own distractions to deal with alongside all the shenanigans going on in the city. Jenny’s love interest is Zac. Zac is clearly interested in Jenny because he invites her to the concert that evening but Lola being Lola makes the mistake of turning him down as Jenny. Luckily, Jenny is able to correct this miscommunication and the two begin dating shortly after. Young love, isn’t it sweet? Zac was played by Kevin Quinn, who had starred as Xander in the first two seasons of the Disney Channel series Bunk’d before going on to appear in Hallmark’s A Christmas Love Story (2019) as Danny and Netflix’s A Week Away (2021) as Will.

Lola has her sights set on the officer who gives her a parking ticket at the start of Adventures in Babysitting, even trying to claim that she’s a fan of classical music just to impress him, though Officer James quickly realises that she isn’t! Officer James later appears at the point that Lola has been arrested for attempting to resell the concert ticket and then shows up to return her driving license on her way home. I find their relationship a little bit random, a little bit unrealistic, and a little bit forced, but perhaps it wouldn’t have been fair for Jenny to get her man and for Lola not to? Officer James was played by Max Lloyd-Jones, who was cast in the role of Tom Thornton in When Calls the Heart (2015-24).

Finally, I’ll just quickly mention the two men chasing the group through the city: the Scalper and Tiny, the pawn shop owner, who I didn’t know even had a name – I clearly wasn’t paying much attention to them to notice anyone saying his name! These two are meant to be threatening but they are actually just two buffoons who don’t have a clue what they are doing, easily being outsmarted by these kids all because they want Lola to delete the picture of them with the stolen ferret. It wouldn’t have been too much to ask Lola nicely to delete the photo and frankly, Lola should’ve done because it’s not nice to take pictures of people without their consent. So, the whole evening would’ve been a lot easier had all of them just opened their mouths and communicated! Scalper was played by Ken Lawson and Tiny was played by Michael P. Northey.

MUSIC

The first song to appear in Adventures in Babysitting is “Wildside”, at the start of the movie, as Lola and Jenny are preparing for their photography internship interview. It also plays during the End Credits. “Wildside” was performed by Sofia Carson and Sabrina Carpenter, with Carpenter also co-writing the song. The music video was released on 10th June 2016, two weeks before the premiere date of Adventures in Babysitting, and shows clips from the film. It’s a good song and I enjoy it; but if I think about Adventures in Babysitting, it’s not the song I’m going to remember the most…

That would be the song “We’re the Babysitters”, which was also performed by both Sofia Carson and Sabrina Carpenter, and written by Brandon N. Caddell. Unfortunately, the reason it is so memorable is because of its cringey rap battle. It was obviously the point for Jenny to feel awkward about rapping, as it’s not her style and she’s never done it before – she’s also being forced to do it, or she can’t leave the rap club – but the whole scene is a bit embarrassing to watch, even when it becomes less of a rap battle and more of a hip-hop song. This scene is an updated, more modern version of the Blues singing that is performed by the babysitter during the 1987 Adventures in Babysitting.

Sabrina Carpenter herself has stated that she is embarrassed by her performance during this rap battle, as it resurfaces online occasionally. She was not a fan of this scene and would rather nobody mentioned it anymore[1]. So, let’s keep this between us and not torture her with the memory of it all over again, ok? She needn’t feel embarrassed by it anyway; pretty much all DCOMs have a cringey scene or some awkward line in it somewhere so she’s not alone in feeling this way!

The other credited song is “Put Your Hands Up”, also written by Brandon N. Caddell. I have no idea where this appears in the movie; skipping through it didn’t give me any hints either, so I am uncertain what this song actually is, but it’s listed in the End Credits so I thought I’d better mention it anyway. It could be a song without lyrics, making it hard to distinguish amongst the rest of the instrumental background music.

There is also the song that plays as Jenny, Lola, and the kids rush to clean up the Anderson’s house before the parents come home. This is “You Ain’t Never Seen It Done Like This” by Photronique. This song is uncredited in Adventures in Babysitting.

Two other pieces of music that are uncredited are Lola and Jenny’s ringtones. Seeing as the music only plays for a few seconds at a time, this is understandable, but for anyone who is interested, Jenny’s ringtone is “Für Elise” by Beethoven, as stated by Officer James, and Lola’s is “Rule the World” by Anabel Englund.

PRODUCTION

As I’ve already mentioned, Disney Channel’s Adventures in Babysitting is not an original idea; it is a remake of the 1987 film of the same name.

With the 1987 Adventures in Babysitting being a PG-13 rated movie, there were many scenes that would’ve needed to be changed to fit the target audience of a DCOM. Some of the scenes that appeared in the 1987 film and not the 2016 film include the group seeing evidence of car theft, gang fights, going to a fraternity party, as well as guns and even a Playboy magazine being frequently seen. Adventures in Babysitting reached ninth place at the box office on its opening on 3rd July 1987 but became a “sleeper hit”, which is still watched decades later.

Star of Adventures in Babysitting, Elisabeth Shue, said that she had not seen the 2016 film, but that she had seen a picture of Sabrina Carpenter wearing the same coat as her character had in the original movie. Shue also stated that she felt remaking the movie in present day wouldn’t feel the same since having mobile phones makes everything a lot easier for people, so they can just call someone and fix the problem. Phones don’t make a big difference to the plot of the 2016 movie but I can see what Shue means there[2].

The 1987 Adventures in Babysitting is still available to watch on Disney+, however, it has been noticed by viewers that actually two lines that both use “the f-word” have been edited out of the Disney+ version, annoying some fans[3]. It now says “don’t fool with…” and it’s only too obvious that these lines were changed!

But back to the 2016 Adventures in Babysitting. It had been announced years before that Disney were going to be making a remake, however, it had been so long since that announcement that many believed the remake had been scrapped. Raven-Symoné was once linked to an early version of the film which was being worked on around 2006[4]. It wasn’t until 9th January 2015 that Disney Channel officially announced they would in fact be making a remake of Adventures in Babysitting, with Sabrina Carpenter and Sofia Carson confirmed as the stars of the new movie, playing two different babysitters. The first official trailer for the movie was released in February 2016.

The DCOM Adventures in Babysitting was filmed in British Columbia, Canada, however, it is unclear where exactly the movie is set, with the 1987 film being set in Chicago. Some have stated that it is supposedly meant to be set in Chicago as well, but with no specific filming locations linking the 2016 movie to Chicago, it actually just becomes an undetermined big city to me. I assumed it was meant to be New York City originally, but if that had been the case, I’m sure specific locations would have been used. I read one review that said they thought the film was meant to be set in Seattle, others said Vancouver, where it was filmed. It’s probably safer to just say it is a big city, and not be specific about it.

Adventures in Babysitting was directed by John Schultz, who had also directed A Christmas Prince: The Royal Wedding (2018), the second instalment in Netflix’s A Christmas Prince trilogy, and Like Mike (2002) amongst others. The screenplay for the movie was written by Tiffany Paulsen, who went on to write Holidate (2020) and About Fate (2022).

RECEPTION

In order to properly celebrate the huge milestone of Disney Channel releasing their 100th Disney Channel Original Movie, in the lead up to Adventures in Babysitting’s premiere date, Disney Channel aired ALL their previous DCOMs from Memorial Day Weekend in May 2016 through to the premiere of Adventures in Babysitting. The most films – 51 – were shown during that four-date weekend[5]. I wish I’d seen that!

When Adventures in Babysitting did premiere on 24th June 2016, it reportedly reached 3.45 million viewers on that one day. However, seven further showings of the movie in the couple of weeks that followed, saw the viewer total reach 15 million, where it became the top cable TV movie of 2016 to that date[6].

It also received a nomination for an Imagen Award, which supports Latino talent in the entertainment industry, in 2017 for Best Primetime Program: Special, Movies, & Mini-Series, but lost out to ABC’s American Crime (2015-17). John Schultz was also nominated at the Directors Guild of America Awards in 2017, in the category of Outstanding Directing – Children’s Programs, losing out to An American Girl Story – Melody 1963 (2016).

Adventures in Babysitting received a bit of a mixed reception though. On the positive side, many felt that the lead characters of Jenny and Lola were very likeable and that in general, the movie was fun, exciting, and light-hearted entertainment. On the other hand, those who had already been a fan of the 1987 film had a lot of negative comments on Disney Channel’s new remake.

They felt that this was a “sanitised” version of the original film, that the remake doesn’t capture any of the magic or energy of the original, and that too much of the story had been changed. The 2016 Adventures in Babysitting also happened to come at a time when reboots and remakes seemed to be the only thing that film studios and television channels were capable of making, with many viewers already upset or annoyed even just hearing the word “remake”, feeling that creativity is being wiped out by laziness.

I do agree with this general point but as I’ve never seen the 1987 Adventures in Babysitting, I cannot comment on how Disney Channel handled the remake’s story compared to the original. I can understand fans of the original wouldn’t be happy with the DCOM version though, having read some plot points and seen a few clips of it; the two movies are quite different.

For me, I just felt that it was bit long and a bit samey to keep me particularly interesting. It also doesn’t seem to have much of a message, unlike many other Disney Channel movies, apart from maybe don’t lie to your parents. Or don’t sneak out of the house in case you come across illegal activities and end up being chased around a big city at night by two criminals… But that’s a bit too precise for most kids to relate to.

LEGACY

As for what happened next for Adventures in Babysitting, well, there was no sequel. There is ample inspiration and opportunities for another remake to be made, as the story is quite flexible and it’s easy to inject humour and peril into the general idea of kids running around a city without their parents knowing, but the reception to the 2016 film has probably said that the people didn’t want this version, let alone another one, so it’s unlikely to happen from Disney. Perhaps from a different movie studio though.

However, Adventures in Babysitting will always be the 100th Disney Channel Original Movie, so that’s something that cannot be taken away. Although from this point on, the number of DCOMs reduced to only around two per year, whereas “back in the day”, in the 2000s, Disney Channel released 8 to 10 movies in some years, Disney Channel have continued to make television movies that have resonated with the young people of the time and launched the careers of many of their stars. Just look at Adventures in Babysitting – Sabrina Carpenter has become a global superstar since her “Disney days”.

FINAL THOUGHTS

Adventures in Babysitting wasn’t for me. I didn’t find the overall premise entertaining and sadly the lead actresses of Sofia Carson and Sabrina Carpenter couldn’t keep me interested either, although I did like their characters, Lola and Jenny.

It also doesn’t look like I would’ve enjoyed the original 1987 film either – it has some quite intense moments from what I have seen – so it’s not like being a fan of that has clouded my judgement of this DCOM. 

Perhaps if I’d been a more rebellious, outgoing, extroverted kid, or even just a babysitter, I might have been able to relate to some aspects of Adventures in Babysitting but I was not ever that, not even close. I’m not even like that now as an adult – I still can’t lie to my parents, or run around a city at night without feeling terrified! 

Should I get out more and be more adventurous? Maybe – but please don’t make me go out with a group of kids and two babysitters; I don’t think my nerves could cope. 


REFERENCES

[1] Credit: Cosmopolitan, ‘Sabrina Carpenter Is Haunted By This Scene and Asks Us to “Burn It”’, Cosmopolitan YouTube Channel, 27th March 2024.

[2] Credit: Mara Reinstein, ‘Elisabeth Shue Answers Every Question We Have About Adventures in Babysitting’, Vulture.com, 3rd September 2021.

[3] Credit: Noah Dominguez, ‘Fans Notice Disney+ Edits Out Elisabeth Shue’s Iconic Adventures in Babysitting Line’, CBR.com, 14th January 2022.

[4] Credit: Marc Snetiker, ‘Adventures in Babysitting trailer: Disney’s ‘80s revival exclusive’, EW.com, 12th February 2016.

[5] Credit: Nicole Nalty, ‘The Ultimate Guide to Disney Channel’s DCOM Marathon’, D23.com, 27th May 2016.

[6] Credit: Tony Maglio, ‘Disney Channel’s ‘Adventures in Babysitting’ Is Top Cable TV Movie of 2016’, TheWrap.com, 11th July 2016.